Re:A German ISP tampered with their DNS – specifically to sa...
by mnw21cam on Sunday August 24, 2025 @08:10AM
(#45003631)
The best counter-argument I can provide to your wonderful ideal is that people are stupid, and they are vulnerable to being manipulated into believing dangerous peace-disrupting falsehoods by propaganda.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:A German ISP tampered with their DNS – specifically to sa...
by moron4hire on Sunday August 24, 2025 @08:27AM
(#45003739)
If the people are too stupid to discern propaganda from truth, then they are too stupid to vote.
Re:A German ISP tampered with their DNS – specifically to sa...
by jdiff on Sunday August 24, 2025 @09:49AM
(#45004239)
Nobody is immune to propaganda. Thinking you are paradoxically makes you more susceptible.
Re:A German ISP tampered with their DNS – specifically to sa...
by littlecranky67 on Sunday August 24, 2025 @08:59AM
(#45003947)
Spinning your thoughts further, you assume that stupidity is not some kind of freedom that you get to enjoy in a democracy. The opposite is true, people are free to be stupid, and if the majority is stupid, the smart people have to give in to the fact that stupid people make the rules (by voting).
The whole idea of supressing stupidity in a democracy leads to some sort of elitist society.
Re:A German ISP tampered with their DNS – specifically to sa...
by Barrin92 on Sunday August 24, 2025 @10:10AM
(#45004372)
>The whole idea of supressing stupidity in a democracy leads to some sort of elitist society.
there's nothing wrong with this. Stable democracies tend to be republican and elitist. One of the reasons why the US has been, until recently, an exceptionally stable country was because decision making was largely insulated from the whims of the public. Democracy properly understood is best used as a tool for legitimacy and as a check against the worst abuses of power, not actually as a tool for decision making.
Having the inmates run the asylum is generally a bad idea, we've known this since Plato.