News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cindy Gallop’s Online Effort to Promote ‘Real,’ Not Porn-... by pessimizer on Monday September 10, 2012 @08:48AM (#4499454)
Porn as prescriptive propaganda. There's already, and has always been, a market for depictions of non-crazy sex between couples in a relationship. It's just a minor market amoungst many, and IMO, not any less perverse and odd.

Complaining about porn not being real is similar to claiming soccer isn't real. "Real people don't run that fast." "He's just trying to impress the cameras." "What he just did was super dangerous." But it is real, because those are human beings having sex, so if "real" as a word has any meaning, it's real. But the word is being used as a prescriptive code as in the phrase "real women," which simply means "women who are not thin."

Just because models being used in "real" campaigns are not thin does not make them representative of the general population - they are more attractive, their bodies in rarer proportions, they are still thinner, and they lack the actually thin - because 'real'ness is simply a reaction to thiness. The usage of the word "real" in that industry is simply disguising that reaction as a call to authenticity, something that advertisers have done since the beginning of advertising.

If the models were as the general population, why would anyone pay to look at them? If professional footballers played the same game as wekend footballers, why would anyone pay to look at them? If people in porn looked like you and your girlfriend and had sex like you and your girlfriend, why would you pay to watch?

If "real" models become the standard, and you are a thin person, will you have to go underground to find representations of people like you in the media?

I'm just being silly, though. This clarion call for real porn is cyclical, and predictable in its failure - because that market is already being pandered to, and because most people would rather have real sex tham watch it. We have terms for people who want to watch averagely attractive people have average sex within a loving relationship. Peeping Toms.

Re:Cindy Gallop’s Online Effort to Promote ‘Real,’ Not Porn-... by ForrestN on Monday September 10, 2012 @09:02AM (#4499521)
I think you misunderstood. She doesn't mean "real sex" as in normal-looking people. She means real sex in terms of behavior. The article says the site is a reaction to young men who have sex in the manner of porn (which I assume means a certain amount of macho performance, posing, a manner of making sounds and talking during sex, etc.) as opposed to the manner in which real people tend to have sex.

There is a very BIG market for "amateur porn" which is filled with "normal-looking" people as opposed to porn stars. This is more about education and promoting a different vision of the behavioral side of sex.

Re:Cindy Gallop’s Online Effort to Promote ‘Real,’ Not Porn-... by pessimizer on Monday September 10, 2012 @11:26AM (#4500253)
I didn't. And I agree - the market for normal people having vanilla sex is well served. People who are looking for it, get it. Most people are looking for stunt people having stunt sex.

>This is more about education and promoting a different vision of the behavioral side of sex.

It's moral education, promoting a particular vision of how she thinks people should be having sex. My guess is that it's also going to be a bit puritan, with soft focus, obstructive camera angles and a lot of cuts. It will probably make people whose sex lives are pretty statistically normal feel perverted and judged.