Re:Should Bogus Copyright Takedown Senders Be Punished?
by icebraining on Sunday September 09, 2012 @05:07PM
(#4496996)
I read parent's post as taking about self-censoring bots like Youtube's Content-ID, and not DMCA sending bots. As far as I know, Google doesn't use the latter.
Re:Should Bogus Copyright Takedown Senders Be Punished?
by xtdx on Monday September 10, 2012 @01:36AM
(#4498459)
So if gmail's spam filter isn't perfect, it's better to have no spam filter?
Re:Should Bogus Copyright Takedown Senders Be Punished?
by bpatrianakos on Thursday September 13, 2012 @10:18AM
(#4516227)
No, exactly the opposite. I'm saying if you can't have perfect then take the next best thing. In your example the next best thing would be taking an imperfect spam filter over none at all.
Furthermore, I'm not sure how YC deleting a post and issuing a DMCA takedown request against content on their own site are the same thing. This isn't about deleting content at all. Whether a site deletes content isn't at issue whether it violates copyright or not. The issue is sending bogus takedown requests to others.