Re:Closer to the Metal: Leaving Playwright for CDP
by nikisweeting on Wednesday August 20, 2025 @01:51PM
(#44964278)
whats the downside of using frameId/targetId+backendNodeId as the stable element ids?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Closer to the Metal: Leaving Playwright for CDP
by hugs on Wednesday August 20, 2025 @03:35PM
(#44965500)
i'm at the edge of my chrome internals knowledge here, but i'd answer the question with a question: isn't backendnodeid only stable within a single session?
that might not matter if the agent is re-finding the element between sessions anyway, but then you're paying a lookup cost (time + tokens) each time. compared to just using document.getelementbyid() on an explicit id.
Re:Closer to the Metal: Leaving Playwright for CDP
by nikisweeting on Wednesday August 20, 2025 @04:04PM
(#44965847)
iirc it's stable across sessions until the tab closes, even though their docs dont guarantee it.
we cant modify the dom to add IDs because we'd get detected by block-blockers very quickly. we're gradually trying to get rid of all DOM tampering entirely for that reason.