Btw, living in the country and working in the city is a luxury. And in terms of the suburbs to save money, you can usually find employment that's closer or find a decent solution that can simplify communiting. People do it everyday ;)
The reason that there are TV shows about that kind of thing is because the occurrences are far enough out on the bell curve that people can get the entertainment from "watching the stupid people", combined with the frisson of moral-superiority-combined-with-just-enough-fear-for-their-own-situations.
If it was typical, the TV show wouldn't exist.
Of course, having a phone number is a luxury, too. There's certainly no mandate to have one, but let's say that $7-8/mo is allowable. They're in debt. They can get an answering machine from somewhere and take the calls at home.
With that $12 they save, and directly applied as payments to principal, they should be able to save half a payment off a 20 year student loan.
Not bad.
Also, how many of these same people have tv's with cable? Cell phones with data plans? Go out for diners, drinks with friends, and so on?
When I graduated I spent 3-4 years paying down my debt as quickly as possible. I believe I got my first car, and it was for under $1000, when I was in my late 20's. I just couldn't afford one.
I also noticed at least one example of someone also buying a home with a $100,000+ debt. That to me is just a bad financial decision. Anything happens and your in trouble.
Also I did notice a lot of the examples showed degrees where getting a job would be tougher, or that it wouldn't pay that well compared to the cost of the debt. I hate to say this, but not all degrees are created equal, and in today's world you need to evaluate the cost to benefit. Unfortunately for some degrees, you can only really acquire them if you have disposable income because there's no way you can make a profit.
In any case, the most common theme I noticed was that they couldn't afford the debt with their other expenses. But the author rarely discussed what they were. For me a car is a luxury. Tv is a luxury. Anything beyond the most basic $20/mth cell is a luxury. Going out for drinks and suppers is a luxury. Just saying... ;)