Re:The ban on electronic devices rests on anecdotes
by cheald on Monday September 10, 2012 @02:01AM
(#4498516)
The strength (and capability to interfere) of EM radiation is subject to the inverse-square law. You would cook yourself long before your phone could put out enough juice to interfere with the cockpit.
If you can disrupt a speaker's magnetic field by placing a phone 3 inches from it, then you would need 16,000 times as much power to perform the same disruption from 10 feet away.
If every passenger in a 149-seat Boeing 737 had a cell phone, and you daisy-chained them all together to produce an EM pulse, you could improve your disruption distance to 3 feet without anything in between your output and the target to disrupt.
It's trivially easy to see analogue mobile telephones disrupting a wide variety of electronics. Luckily, no one uses analogue phones anymore. It's trivially easy to get a GSM phone to disrupt other electronics. (The burbling noise you hear over a nearby radio when the phone connects to the cell tower is one example.)
Airline safety is conservative. Very many people travel by plane. (Over 133 million just in London each year.)
Being conservative is probably a good thing.
But how are the rules supposed to change? Given that many people think these rules are nonsense, how should the regulatory bodies test phones on planes?