Re:Lab-Grown Salmon Hits the Menu at an Oregon Restaurant as...
by glenstein on Monday August 18, 2025 @11:50PM
(#44948093)
> So waving away Beyond/Impossible as safe
As I said, they measurably improve health outcomes relative to the meats they're replacing in important areas.
My understanding of the studies on UPF health outcomes is that their data is drawn overwhelmingly from traditional categories like junk food and processed starch and sugar. Which is all the more reason to avoid the equivocation between the two categories, lest someone get the mistaken impression that the Twinkie data is about the burgers.
Re:Lab-Grown Salmon Hits the Menu at an Oregon Restaurant as...
by dragonwriter on Monday August 18, 2025 @11:55PM
(#44948112)
> As I said, they measurably improve health outcomes relative to the meats they're replacing
They imitate meats, but is there any evidence that, in practice, they replace them? In menus, and I suspect in actual human eating behavior, they seem to replace earlier vegetarian options like old-school TVP, not meat.
Re:Lab-Grown Salmon Hits the Menu at an Oregon Restaurant as...
by erikerikson on Tuesday August 19, 2025 @12:14AM
(#44948203)
We have eaten impossible burgers as a replacement of beef burgers we would have otherwise eaten on burger night. Some of us even prefer the flavor but the prices are sometimes higher than beef and that reduced our consumption (at that moment we were tighter). If they were substantially less expensive we would have had to financially rationalize beef, beyond the health and environmental rationalizations.
Frankly I think the bigger reason these don't seem to be working out is that they aren't having the actual impact desired. The price isn't coming down. And if the price remains at higher-than-meat levels the ecological impact (which is what I personally care more about) is probably not where it needs to be either.
I mean, let's be blunt: all this dithering about health effects and environmental externalities isn't actually going to change anything. Make a burger for the price of a bean dip, however, and the market will beat your door down even if they claim not to care about the hippy nonsense.