News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The "Wash my Ferrari" Problem: A Meditation on Risk by chime on Saturday September 08, 2012 @03:08PM (#4493683)
> Not to nitpick but managing supply-chain risk is a lot more complicated than insurance.

I agree. I manage an ERP system at a pharma-manufacturer. I added a YMMV precisely because of the different situation - different impact reasons. My main point was:

    Incumbent Sales Price SP1 = Cost of (Base + Risk + CYA-buffers) + Predetermined Margin
    Incumbent Profits     PR1 = SP1 - Total Actual Cost

    Startups Sales Price  SP2 = Cost of (Base + Risk) + Predetermined Margin
    Startups Profits      PR2 = SP2 - Total Actual Cost
If you assume Cost of (Base + Risk) to be relatively on-par then SP1 > SP2 because SP1 includes CYA-buffers. The problem is that when incumbents become lean and shave off overhead, they can continue to command high prices due to entrenched contracts and make a much larger profits. This reinforces their position in the industry, making it harder for startups to compete.

Sidenote: While in a perfectly competitive market, the sales price should be determined by the intersection of supply and demand curves, instead of being a predetermined markup based on cost, in most contract manufacturing environments, all the costs are known, markups are expected, and thoroughly negotiated.

There are no comments on this comment yet.