Re:Why Love Matters Most
by lucyjojo on Saturday August 16, 2025 @08:23PM
(#44927943)
if you make it a rule to do the most horrible things to children and women and men and the elderly, would it then be moral?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
That would mean harming themselves and everyone they know. Who would agree to that and why? Such a person would not be of sound mind, and fit to be in a position make judgment on these matters.
State your case for this absurd rule. To paraphrase Hitchens, that which is asserted casually can be dismissed casually.
Many people do not have mind. That's why they stab each other with blunt instruments due to "disrespect".
A rule to harm people systematically cannot be moral because it contradicts the very point of morality
but we started with "morality is grounded in rules". what does "grounded in" means then?
how would you define morality?