Re:Compiler Bug Causes Compiler Bug: How a 12-Year-Old G++ B...
by DokDidhuAd on Friday August 15, 2025 @07:29PM
(#44918461)
Yeah, C++ is just batshit insane.
> In C++, when you write an expression like a == b, the compiler chooses among available operator== implementations by comparing their match quality. A member function like a.operator==(b) usually has higher priority than a non-member function like operator==(a, b) — unless the types differ too much or are ambiguous.
This is the largest foot-bazooka ever. The point of operator overloading is that the operator in a given expression look natural, feel natural, and behave naturally (= function intuitively). If you have multiple possible operators that could apply, for the same syntax, then you're in a worse position than you originally were -- where an operator either did one particular thing, or didn't apply at all. What operator overloading does in practice is introduce ambiguity. Which is self-defeating. You are better off with C-style, named, non-overloaded functions.
You will never find this crap in actual math. "match quality" my ass.
> In C++, when you write an expression like a == b, the compiler chooses among available operator== implementations by comparing their match quality. A member function like a.operator==(b) usually has higher priority than a non-member function like operator==(a, b) — unless the types differ too much or are ambiguous.
This is the largest foot-bazooka ever. The point of operator overloading is that the operator in a given expression look natural, feel natural, and behave naturally (= function intuitively). If you have multiple possible operators that could apply, for the same syntax, then you're in a worse position than you originally were -- where an operator either did one particular thing, or didn't apply at all. What operator overloading does in practice is introduce ambiguity. Which is self-defeating. You are better off with C-style, named, non-overloaded functions.
You will never find this crap in actual math. "match quality" my ass.