News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A proposal for improving HN : it should cost a user Karma... by forrestthewoods on Friday September 07, 2012 @03:35PM (#4490777)
Any solution relying on karma is doomed to fail imo.

Karma is easy to min-max. I've gotten good at it. Only ~1200 karma but I'm averaging over 10 per post. It's easy with a bit of practice.

None of my comments are particularly good. They typically express a mostly safe opinion in a mild manner. I don't like to make non-root posts as they rarely get upvotes and I hesitate to post in a large thread (like this one) as it's easy to get buried.

I don't even know why I post this way to be honest. I was mostly just curious to see how high I could get my average. The bar to get upvotes on HN seemed really high at first and I wanted to be a good poster. Now I see the road to karma is paved with safe, fluffy comments.

Re:A proposal for improving HN : it should cost a user Karma... by stcredzero on Friday September 07, 2012 @03:45PM (#4490834)
I will corroborate this, from the POV of someone who has been here a long while. (> 13000) Commenting and downvoting has gotten less thoughtful around here of late. I especially note that there's a lot of knee-jerk downvoting by people who seem to read carelessly.
Re:A proposal for improving HN : it should cost a user Karma... by wamatt on Saturday September 08, 2012 @07:22AM (#4492769)
Yeah I noticed this too.

Sadly there also seems to be an emphasis on style and tone, instead of the content of the message.

Re:A proposal for improving HN : it should cost a user Karma... by zerostar07 on Friday September 07, 2012 @04:20PM (#4491007)
Wow that is very insightful. I 'm surprised that even here people are willingly conformists to gain acceptance.
Re:A proposal for improving HN : it should cost a user Karma... by forrestthewoods on Friday September 07, 2012 @04:41PM (#4491089)
I think it started with the 500 karma requirement for downvoting. I wanted the ability to downvote so I min-maxed my comments to get there quickly. After that trying to increase my average is just a way to see if I'm improving.

I don't view it as conforming or trying to gain acceptance. It's more like a silly game. It does have potential value as it's good practice for interacting with the media and making company blog posts.

Re:A proposal for improving HN : it should cost a user Karma... by sliverstorm on Friday September 07, 2012 @06:52PM (#4491583)
Don't be. People conform everywhere, all the time. HN isn't that special.
Re:A proposal for improving HN : it should cost a user Karma... by finalcut on Saturday September 08, 2012 @11:48AM (#4493147)
I don't think the fact that people conform is surprising. What is, possibly, surprising is that someone laid it out there - that they are being a conformist.

Typically, in my experience, people aren't that honest with themselves.