Re:Meta accessed women's health data from Flo app without co...
by gruez on Thursday August 14, 2025 @07:47PM
(#44907064)
>Should large corporations be able to break the law because [...]
No, because this is begging the question. The point being disputed is whether facebook offering a SDK and analytics service counts as "intentionally eavesdropping". Anyone with a bit of understanding of how SDKs work should think it's not. If you told your menstrual secrets to a friend, and that friend then told me, that's not "eavesdropping" to any sane person, but that's essentially what the jury ruled here.
I might be sympathetic if facebook was being convicted of "trafficking private information" or whatever, but if that's not a real crime, we shouldn't be using "intentionally eavesdropping" as a cudgel against it just because we hate it. That goes against the whole concept of rule of law.
No, because this is begging the question. The point being disputed is whether facebook offering a SDK and analytics service counts as "intentionally eavesdropping". Anyone with a bit of understanding of how SDKs work should think it's not. If you told your menstrual secrets to a friend, and that friend then told me, that's not "eavesdropping" to any sane person, but that's essentially what the jury ruled here.
I might be sympathetic if facebook was being convicted of "trafficking private information" or whatever, but if that's not a real crime, we shouldn't be using "intentionally eavesdropping" as a cudgel against it just because we hate it. That goes against the whole concept of rule of law.