News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Brilliant illustrations bring this 1976 Soviet edition of... by CGMthrowaway on Thursday August 14, 2025 @09:19AM (#44900063)
>Her version turned out controversial because Gollum is a giant compared to Bilbo. Turns out Tolkien hadn't described Gollum's size anywhere

Cain and Abel, whom Deagol and Smeagol (Gollum) parallel, may have been giant themselves, given that Adam (their father) is specified in certain religious /apocryphal texts as being 60-100 cubits tall, or 90-150 feet.

Re:Brilliant illustrations bring this 1976 Soviet edition of... by antx on Thursday August 14, 2025 @04:23PM (#44905232)
that's a wild theory, considering that Tolkien himself described Gollum to be "a small, slimy creature" after the revisions, probably because of Jansson's depiction of him. and although the parallel is clear between many characters of the Hobbit and the Bible, do you have any credible sources that Tolkien took inspiration from apocryphal texts (or in this case the Hadith) ?
Re:Brilliant illustrations bring this 1976 Soviet edition of... by CGMthrowaway on Thursday August 14, 2025 @06:13PM (#44906316)
Not in this specific case. There are other examples that could be brought up, such as the Gift of Men (death), which may draw on the Book of Jubilees which suggests that death was given to man to limit wickedness and allow for renewal. Or Book of Enoch and the fall of Numenor. "Credible sources" will be difficult to procure as Tolkien notably avoided citing specific influences when discussing his works