Re:Geneva makes public transport temporarily free to combat ...
by aqme28 on Wednesday August 13, 2025 @11:25AM
(#44889702)
I don't want to comment on if it should be free or not, but public transit and micromobility should always be cheaper than owning+driving a car. Even with NYC's controversial new congestion pricing, it's still cheaper to drive your family to the city than to take them via train.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Geneva makes public transport temporarily free to combat ...
by kccqzy on Wednesday August 13, 2025 @11:35AM
(#44889845)
No it's absolutely not cheaper to drive your family into the city. You said owning+driving a car; did you really take into account ownership costs (maintenance, insurance etc) and driving costs (tolls, parking)? Just the cost of parking alone dwarfs the cost of the train.
Re:Geneva makes public transport temporarily free to combat ...
by IshKebab on Wednesday August 13, 2025 @02:09PM
(#44891814)
Sure but most families need a car anyway, and once you have one the costs of ownership, maintenance, insurance etc. are irrelevant to the costs of individual trips.
Re:Geneva makes public transport temporarily free to combat ...
by const_cast on Wednesday August 13, 2025 @02:55PM
(#44892357)
Most families in NYC do not need to own a car, and in fact most don't.
But even then we have to consider marginal costs. Owning one car is better than two or three. Here in Texas, it's not uncommon to see households with 4 or 5 cars.
That's expensive.
Re:Geneva makes public transport temporarily free to combat ...
by somecontext on Thursday August 14, 2025 @08:06AM
(#44899439)
According to this graphic https://www.hunterurban.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/Car-L... 57.3% of children (0--18yo) are in a household with a car. There's a weighting issue here, but I'd still bet that most families in NYC have a car.
Re:Geneva makes public transport temporarily free to combat ...
by const_cast on Thursday August 14, 2025 @10:37AM
(#44900912)
Well 57% is most, although that doesn't account for having multiple kids in one household.
Either way it's close, and the closer you get to Manhattan the higher that number goes. Remember, there are over 8 million people in NYC, and over 12 million during the work day.
Re:Geneva makes public transport temporarily free to combat ...
by Mawr on Wednesday August 13, 2025 @10:07PM
(#44896019)
You want to buy a second-hand car. What's the first thing you check? Yep, the mileage. The cost of a car is basically down to its depreciation, which is basically down to its mileage.
Re:Geneva makes public transport temporarily free to combat ...
by IshKebab on Thursday August 14, 2025 @08:35AM
(#44899654)
It's not only the mileage. Age is very important too. Look at any car advert - it's the age that is highlighted first. Mileage only if it is unusually low.
Many components degrade simply due to time, especially things like rubber seals.
Re:Geneva makes public transport temporarily free to combat ...
by aqme28 on Thursday August 14, 2025 @04:06AM
(#44897963)
A family of 4 is charged $2.90x2 in subway fares, which is more than the $15 congestion price for a car.
Re:Geneva makes public transport temporarily free to combat ...
by colechristensen on Wednesday August 13, 2025 @11:33AM
(#44889815)
Commuting as one person from Mountain View to SF was cheaper with a car including the total ownership cost of the car, nevermind the reasonable discount for "stuff I wand to do with my car other than commute".
And riding caltrain during peak hours for an hour twice a day would violate the Geneva Convention on the treatment of prisoners of war.
Re:Geneva makes public transport temporarily free to combat ...
by bkettle on Wednesday August 13, 2025 @11:43AM
(#44889950)
Riding Caltrain during peak hours is totally fine and not unpleasant at all, particularly with the new trains (I do it most days and am writing this comment while doing so)
Re:Geneva makes public transport temporarily free to combat ...
by colechristensen on Wednesday August 13, 2025 @11:52AM
(#44890084)
I left California before the new trains were a thing, but peak hours going north starting in Mountain View meant standing room only tightly packed on the world's more unstable train cars.