News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A proposal for improving HN : it should cost a user Karma... by shin_lao on Friday September 07, 2012 @08:20AM (#4488669)
The downward spiral feeling comes from after reading HN for a while, you start to reread the same articles and same comments.

It does not mean HN gets worse and worse, it means you extract less and less value.

Re:A proposal for improving HN : it should cost a user Karma... by ChuckMcM on Friday September 07, 2012 @10:29AM (#4489228)
I feel like this is closer to the root cause. People start out and everything is new, and they have this huge sense of wonder about what is going on around them in the valley, and then after a year or two you realize that bigger picture moves more slowly, a lot of people re-invent the wheel, Etc.

But the conversations are actually nearly the same quality, they are just re-hashes of conversations you already know the answers too. Sometimes you'll get someone who is quite disgruntled from the it and that will be a pain until they stop but for the most part it seems to be ok.

That said, if every submission only had one comment 'see link to previous discussions of this form' that would be pretty boring too.

Re:A proposal for improving HN : it should cost a user Karma... by 127001brewer on Friday September 07, 2012 @02:21PM (#4490452)
... wonder about what is going on around them in the valley ...

Why does it have to be mainly about Silicon Valley? I like to think that there are a lot of interesting people and companies outside Silicon Valley.

In my opinion, there can be a lot noise here, but the quality postings and comments are much, much better than anywhere else. And, yes, the bigger picture moves more slowly than a lot of us would like. But isn't that the way things work?

Re:A proposal for improving HN : it should cost a user Karma... by jseliger on Friday September 07, 2012 @12:55PM (#4490036)
It does not mean HN gets worse and worse, it means you extract less and less value.

Maybe someone (me?) should write "HN: The Book." Chapters might include:

1. Silicon Valley life.

2. Structured/conventional education versus self-education.

3. What you do with your tools is more interesting than the tools themselves, and many people have used bad tools to make cool things, though that in itself isn't an excuse for bad tools.

4. Problems with politics.

5. Commenting on commenting.

Actually, I started this list as a joke, but I'm starting to wonder if it shouldn't be. . .

Re:A proposal for improving HN : it should cost a user Karma... by leeHS on Friday September 07, 2012 @08:52AM (#4488764)
I'm relatively new to HN, and also learning to program. I don't comment much. I rarely submit. But I read pretty much everything, including the comments.

And when I see posts about improving HN, I must admit that I just don't see it. Yes some comments are not constructive, but you'll always have that. I'm surprised we don't have more of this to be honest.

So is there a correlation between time spend on HN and your personal view of it's quality? Good question. How do you measure quality then? How do you separate yourself out?

Re:A proposal for improving HN : it should cost a user Karma... by ImprovedSilence on Friday September 07, 2012 @09:52AM (#4489000)
I couldn't agree more. Also, there are plenty of run of the mill "news" articles from tech crunch et. al. But there are still more than plenty of interesting programming/hacker articles and nuggets of goodness posted.
Re:A proposal for improving HN : it should cost a user Karma... by danso on Friday September 07, 2012 @09:15AM (#4488852)
I thought the negative perception was due to the effect of nostalgia for old times, but this is an even better explanation. Everything is exciting and more stimulating at first, that's how the brain works. Of course after a few years, that feeling of freshness is going to be lessened, even if the actual overall quality is better.