News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A proposal for improving HN : it should cost a user Karma... by rlt3 on Friday September 07, 2012 @08:15AM (#4488658)
The problem, as with all great communities, seems to be the abundance of new users and, thus, the widening of scope on submissions and comments.

To me, it seems obvious that to improve HN, the community needs to stop expanding as much and get its main user base back to a niche.

The only tried and true method (that I know of) would be to follow Something Awful and start charging for an account. Something trivial, like $2, would be fine.

Of course, this will never happen. This isn't really something I want to happen, but, to me, it seems to be the only way of limiting the user base in an effective manner.

Re:A proposal for improving HN : it should cost a user Karma... by sgdesign on Friday September 07, 2012 @08:20AM (#4488666)
Why not just have optional pro accounts that people can get for a fee? "Pro" tags would be a quick way to make "serious" posters visually distinctive.
Re:A proposal for improving HN : it should cost a user Karma... by rlt3 on Friday September 07, 2012 @08:24AM (#4488683)
I feel that this creates elitism. Anyone can buy a 'Pro' tag. What makes a person's comments, who is willing to spend money, better than one who is not?
Re:A proposal for improving HN : it should cost a user Karma... by Spearchucker on Friday September 07, 2012 @08:29AM (#4488700)
I think that brings up new problems, e.g. dealing with someone with a paid account/subscription that submits enough posts or comments to get that person banned or hell-banned. Or a scenario in which a hell-banned user wants to upgrade to a paid account.
Re:A proposal for improving HN : it should cost a user Karma... by abailin on Friday September 07, 2012 @08:19AM (#4488665)
Although what's $2 for a site that I check every day?
Re:A proposal for improving HN : it should cost a user Karma... by verroq on Friday September 07, 2012 @08:34AM (#4488714)
I disagree, it has to be something substantial, at least $10. The more you charge, the more value it has.
Re:A proposal for improving HN : it should cost a user Karma... by rlt3 on Friday September 07, 2012 @08:37AM (#4488731)
I can see your point. But the objective is to just create a barrier, no matter how small. Many people wouldn't pay $2 for an account on some internet forum.
Re:A proposal for improving HN : it should cost a user Karma... by verroq on Friday September 07, 2012 @08:49AM (#4488751)
If it's too little, people will feel it's not worth the effort to pay for such an amount.