News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The to-do list problem by tsahyt on Friday September 07, 2012 @08:02AM (#4488617)
Slightly off-topic, but never auto-play video (or audio) content on a website. If I want it to be played, I click on it, otherwise it's just annoying.
Re:The to-do list problem by bluetidepro on Friday September 07, 2012 @09:23AM (#4488873)
I'm glad someone beat me to this. This is the first thing I thought when I went to the post. It soured my opinion of the whole article before I even read it because of that small usability mistake.
Re:The to-do list problem by dkrich on Friday September 07, 2012 @09:44AM (#4488962)
"It soured my opinion of the whole article before I even read it"

Seriously? The fact that an embedded video started playing soured your opinion of the article? Maybe you guys should chill out a bit. Sometimes comments like this lead me to believe the author wants recognition at somebody else's expense.

Re:The to-do list problem by bluetidepro on Friday September 07, 2012 @09:59AM (#4489035)
I'm not saying I didn't read the article because of it but it does just start the article off with a bit of annoyance. You can't argue that anywhere you enjoy going in the online or physical world is determined by emotional responses.

Imagine when you got to a restaurant that has music annoying loud. You may still enjoy the dinner food, but you had a bad experience eating the good food because you were annoyed with the music. That scenario similar to this article. You could still enjoy the article content but you were annoyed because of the bad experience. And after so many of those bad experiences you may just think "you know what, I'd rather eat somewhere not as good just because I won't be annoyed by loud music."

If you don't think that small things like this (that can easily add up over time) do change how your viewers see your site/company (regardless of the content), then you need to think again.

However, I could be wrong. I mean, everyone did love the animated images, colors, and sounds on GeoCities which lead to their industry takeover and incredible success. ;)

Re:The to-do list problem by dkrich on Friday September 07, 2012 @10:16AM (#4489143)
"However, I could be wrong. I mean, everyone did love the animated images, colors, and sounds on GeoCities which lead to their industry takeover and incredible success."

Let's not just assume that all annoyances are created equal. One is an integrally bad user experience, the only way out of which is to stop using the service wholesale. The other amounts to mousing-over a large area of the screen and clicking a button.

Re:The to-do list problem by bluetidepro on Friday September 07, 2012 @10:20AM (#4489166)
Fair enough. I will give you that. It was a bit of a extreme on that example. But I imagine you do understand what I generally mean about the small things having the ability to add up.
Re:The to-do list problem by chollida1 on Friday September 07, 2012 @12:30PM (#4489898)
> Seriously? The fact that an embedded video started playing soured your opinion of the article?

Sure, what's wrong with that opinion. I don't know how you browse but when I browse hacker news I'll open up 2-3 articles and their associated comments and start reading one.

When a video starts playing in the background when I'm not even on that tab, then yes, it can sour your opinion of the entire website.

Little things matter.

Re:The to-do list problem by dkrich on Friday September 07, 2012 @02:29PM (#4490497)
That's your interpretation based on your use. I do not browse that way. I pick one maybe two that look interesting and read them. I find the autoplay useful.

See that? Two different interpretations of the same feature. Just because you hate autoplay doesn't mean everyone does. Certainly one or the other does not "sour my opinion" of an article. The fact that the video starts playing when the page loads has exactly nothing to do with the content in the article. That's what's wrong with the opinion.

Re:The to-do list problem by tsahyt on Friday September 07, 2012 @03:11PM (#4490677)
Browsing habits aside, I find something else annoying about it. When I click on the article, and the video sits in the middle of the page with text above it, I want to read the text until I reach the video, then watch the video, then continue with the text below it. As soon as the video starts, reading is disturbed. To me it completely kills the "flow" of the article.

And just my two cents: There is nothing wrong with any opinion. It's an opinion after all isn't it? An opinion is not a universal truth. It's something personal that people like to share for some reason. That what makes discussion so hard at times.

Re:The to-do list problem by chollida1 on Friday September 07, 2012 @05:20PM (#4491239)
> See that? Two different interpretations of the same feature. Just because you hate autoplay doesn't mean everyone does.

Sure, all that makes perfect sense. None of that invalidates anything that I said though:)

Re:The to-do list problem by antidoh on Friday September 07, 2012 @08:05AM (#4488628)
This is one of the two benefits of flashblock for me. If I want to watch a video, I click on the circled F, otherwise it's just a box that takes up space.

The other benefit is that I don't give my cycles and peace to flash advertisements.

Re:The to-do list problem by tsahyt on Friday September 07, 2012 @08:11AM (#4488648)
The cycles part is actually non-negligible. Those things are usually so horribly written that they'll eat up processing time in big chunks. But that's not a Flash-only problem. I've seen JS-things on webpages actually spinning up my laptops fans even though there was really nothing much on the screen, and it's not like I've got a bad laptop either. It's not high-end but an i7 with 8gb of RAM shouldn't notice the load of a pretty average webpage.

But that's just my 2 cents.

Re:The to-do list problem by ZoFreX on Friday September 07, 2012 @08:52AM (#4488762)
My dad didn't understand why his (admittedly quite old) laptop really struggles on some websites. For most of his usage - buying tickets, checking emails - it suffices just fine, but a badly coded flash advert can bring the entire machine to a crawl.

It was very difficult to convince him that yes, it was actually the crappy slideshow advert on one tab that was making his entire computer unusable.

Re:The to-do list problem by diggan on Friday September 07, 2012 @09:51AM (#4488995)
Agree. Since I tend to skimread the frontpage and open all links I think is interesting in new tabs, autoplay leads to a closed tab without even looking.
Re:The to-do list problem by tomazstolfa on Friday September 07, 2012 @08:40AM (#4488735)
I agree with you. The embed does not have a non-autoplay option.
Re:The to-do list problem by ed209 on Friday September 07, 2012 @09:29AM (#4488893)
that's a bit of a sweeping statement. I would agree with you if the autoplayed video has audio or is instructional in some way. In the article I agree it should not auto-play

However, auto-play can be nice in the right setting. Lots of car manufacturers auto-play video as part of the design. Or some product shots like the MackBook page where the laptop opens and spins is nice.

Re:The to-do list problem by dkrich on Friday September 07, 2012 @09:40AM (#4488945)
I completely disagree. I thought that was pretty cool actually. I rarely view videos embedded in articles unless they autoplay.