Re:Ask HN: What alternatives to GitHub are you using?
by icy on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @10:47AM
(#44876931)
Glad you liked it! Yes, jj's change IDs are very similar to Gerrit's, but instead of a commit trailer it's now a header in the commit object itself. For example:
$ git cat-file commit caa00e20
tree e8418bf7e7c626fdf5b1570e6efcddf1e1b0c923
parent 1e3a841997f81c9b0ed21dc5a91e783fcf2f4ec7
author Anirudh Oppiliappan <[email protected]> 1754996643 +0300
committer Anirudh Oppiliappan <[email protected]> 1754996799 +0300
change-id skwlyzyomnwqntksmoqkrllqlpsskztt
xrpc/{errors,serviceauth}: split shared xrpc code to top-level package
Signed-off-by: Anirudh Oppiliappan <[email protected]>
I've never used Gerrit directly, but I'm guessing that Jujutsu's change IDs are like a native version of what Gerrit does there.
I regularly (attempt to) do stacked diffs on GitHub with jj, and even with a bunch of automations it's still a clunky, awkward experience.
[1] https://blog.tangled.sh/stacking