News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Ed-Tech Bubble by azylman on Thursday September 06, 2012 @07:13PM (#4486800)
It seems like the author is taking a specific subset of ed-tech ("online learning companies that rely on the student's intrinsic motivation") and trying to generalize it to all ed-tech.

There are TONS of different companies doing some really interested stuff in ed-tech. Not only are there lots of ed-tech companies that aren't online learning companies, there are a lot of online learning companies that DON'T rely on a student's intrinsic motivation: e.g. anything in the K12 space - there are a lot of K12 schools that are beginning to incorporate online learning into their curriculum, and then there's plenty of extrinsic (e.g. grade-based) motivation to do well and perform.

I think my #1 takeaway from this is that the author isn't the target market for most of these ed-tech companies. They're not trying to get people to take these classes for fun, no more than colleges want people to take classes for fun.

Re:The Ed-Tech Bubble by lexilewtan on Thursday September 06, 2012 @07:38PM (#4486904)
I'm definitely aware that there are tons of companies doing amazing things. But I think that people are confusing tools for communication with tools for education, and that the distinction is unfortunately larger than the landscape suggests.

Great point about incorporating behavior though - technology that molds and aids existent behavior is always needed!