News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We are all mercantilists now by Findeton on Monday August 11, 2025 @10:53AM (#44864821)
It's sad because Adam Smith wrote The Wealth of Nations in part to debunk Mercantilism. Smith wasn't right on everything, but he was right to criticize Mercantilism.

For example, if trade imbalances were so bad, we should sink any ship that comes into the US as this reduces trade imbalances (absurd example from Bastiat btw).

Re:We are all mercantilists now by TimorousBestie on Monday August 11, 2025 @12:11PM (#44865914)
> we should sink any ship that comes into the US as this reduces trade imbalances

I could see this happening in the near future, as absurd as everything is.

Re:We are all mercantilists now by js8 on Monday August 11, 2025 @12:20PM (#44866048)
Theory of comparative advantage is probably wrong, though. There are huge advantages for a nation in doing (pretty much) everything, and having research close to application, and having tool makers close to their users.

Analogy with human specialization is flawed, because human attention span is limited. Even there the famous Heinlein quote on versatility still applies.

Re:We are all mercantilists now by justonceokay on Monday August 11, 2025 @12:42PM (#44866327)
Competitive advantage is how every small community works. One person runs the coffee shop, someone is the mechanic, there’s the town contractor, plumber, grocer, sheriff, etc. the more each person is able to specialize the more services are available to the whole town.

I understand international politics are completely different, but it is hard for me to understand how comparative advantage would not be useful at that level as well.

Re:We are all mercantilists now by js8 on Monday August 11, 2025 @03:55PM (#44868728)
Comparative advantage somewhat works on international level, but with very specialized stuff. There is no reason every country needs its own space program, its own EUV tooling or its own global positioning system.

But for commonly used goods that every person needs, every country would benefit from producing these on their own, thanks to various synergies.

Specialization has also transaction cost. If you're skilled it might be better to plumb some things yourself than call a professional and risk him being a hack.

So I don't think it's one system being better than other. Rather, specialization is like paralelism - there is a transaction cost due to nonlocality, but also better scaling. So, like with paralelism, the rule should be - try as much as you can to produce locally, and specialize only where the scale advantage becomes really strong (usually that happens with high-tech products that are needed in very low quantities - by centralizing production, knowhow is easier to apply and capital costs are easier to justify).

Re:We are all mercantilists now by energy123 on Monday August 11, 2025 @12:31PM (#44866179)
Juche doesn't work. The theory of comparative advantage is not wrong.
Re:We are all mercantilists now by js8 on Monday August 11, 2025 @03:59PM (#44868757)
But South Korea wasn't using pure comparative advantage either. Ha Joon-Chang mentions that LG was originally a textile company, but the government forced them to expand into cables. And 50 years later.. had they followed comparative advantage, they would still be a textile company.
Re:We are all mercantilists now by imtringued on Monday August 11, 2025 @01:02PM (#44866613)
It's unfalsifiable though. How can comparative advantage be distinguished from being created versus being innate?

If economic actors can choose what comparative advantages they possess (e.g. by moving the economic factors or through training or investment), the theory becomes meaningless. It turns into a predestination fallacy since it myopically focuses on geographical factors that happen to not matter that much in the modern world.

Re:We are all mercantilists now by energy123 on Monday August 11, 2025 @01:15PM (#44866768)
You can falsify it with this experiment. Move into the wilderness and be self sufficient yourself starting tomorrow. Give up all the comparative advantage you currently experience through your trading with other people (labor for money, money for things you can't make). See what happens.
Re:We are all mercantilists now by js8 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @01:55AM (#44872874)
No, first you need to make a formulation of the theory that you're trying to falsify.

What economic advice would the theory of comparative advantage give to China in the 1960s?

If it is "just do the free trade", it would have been wrong. China started to implement its market reforms with dual pricing to protect its own citizens from the foreign markets.

Re:We are all mercantilists now by AstralStorm on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @07:21AM (#44874860)
But it appears their secret sauce is not dual pricing, but horizontal and vertical integration in manufacturing, combined with low labor costs. Same thing the USA companies did earlier.

Now that is an actual comparative advantage that is actually hard to replicate due to huge entry costs.

(To lower the costs of labor further you need to actually give out life basics for free! China gets away with this by having a huge population competing thus far, but it won't hold.)

Re:We are all mercantilists now by linksnapzz on Monday August 11, 2025 @12:34PM (#44866232)
If current trends continue, North Korea will be around longer than South Korea. Ironic, no?
Re:We are all mercantilists now by justonceokay on Monday August 11, 2025 @12:43PM (#44866346)
There is no reason to believe trends will continue. Countries populations are stabilizing, not trending toward zero.
Re:We are all mercantilists now by churchill on Monday August 11, 2025 @12:46PM (#44866396)
How did you make the leap from free markets vs. autarkic Juche to birth rates discourse?

It's unambiguously true that free markets has made South Korea significantly, mind-bendingly wealthier than the North. And on the subject of fertility, birth rates are so low (1.8) that you have Kim Jong Un crying on national TV, begging women to have more kids.

Personally, I have this pet theory (irrational, it may be) that as the boomers die off across the West, newer generations will pick up having more kids and TFR will level off. Like new growth springing up in a forest after a wildfire burns up all the old, dry wood.

Something similar to the post-war baby boom.

Re:We are all mercantilists now by TimorousBestie on Monday August 11, 2025 @12:57PM (#44866556)
[flagged]
Re:We are all mercantilists now by churchill on Monday August 11, 2025 @01:08PM (#44866688)
Exactly this. I believe it'll free up housing and general consumer demand, reduce social security spending, etc.
Re:We are all mercantilists now by geremiiah on Monday August 11, 2025 @12:46PM (#44866403)
Simple models shouldn't be applied without nuance (and that's why I get really annoyed at "engineers" on HN who think they know jack shit about economics because they took econ 101). The idea is sound, but the real world is more complicated. In a simple world model where there are two industries of equal value and two countries with complementary specialization in these industries, it makes sense.

There is an opportunity cost to closing the borders and trying to do everything yourself, which you are not considering.

Re:We are all mercantilists now by jsbg on Monday August 11, 2025 @12:39PM (#44866285)
> There are huge advantages

What are they?

Re:We are all mercantilists now by js8 on Monday August 11, 2025 @04:19PM (#44868965)
When things are produced locally, you get closer to consumer and feedback loop is shorter. (That's why Shenzen is so great as a HW startup hub - if you can get a part in minutes compared to days, prototyping is faster.) You can understand the practical problems with your products better if you can more interact with customers.
Re:We are all mercantilists now by jsbg on Monday August 11, 2025 @07:12PM (#44870507)
Isn't this priced into the product? I don't see how this contradicts comparative advantage.
Re:We are all mercantilists now by js8 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @01:31AM (#44872740)
No, see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44866613. If the theory of comparative advantage is to give any useful advice, it cannot just rely on people doing "the right thing". That will quickly make it into an unfalsifiable tautology.

In this case, you also forget that the pricing signals have a time horizon, which is bounded by the expected time of survival of the private company being non-competitive. But government (society) can take a longer term view than a company that is influenced by pricing signals, See the LG example I gave elsewhere in this thread.

Another reason is incomplete information. Free market works in theory because you assume complete information; in the real world, this is not the case.

Re:We are all mercantilists now by jsbg on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @02:10PM (#44879868)
> the theory of comparative advantage

It's not a theory. Firms trade internationally because it's cheaper, not because they "believe" in free markets.

> But government (society) can take a longer term view than a company that is influenced by pricing signals

Private markets routinely make multi-decade bets; entire industries (mining, energy, infrastructure, biotech) work on 20–100 year horizons. Risk and time are already priced in.

> Free market works in theory because you assume complete information

Free markets don’t "assume" anything; they function through decentralized price signals. And even with imperfect information, dispersed actors still aggregate and react to knowledge far better than any central planner can.

Re:We are all mercantilists now by pydry on Monday August 11, 2025 @12:39PM (#44866290)
The theory of comparative advantage should really be dubbed the theory of static comparative advantage to highlight where it fucked up.

If China believed in it theyd still be making cheap plastic tat. If the west hadnt believed in it China's industrial rise probably wouldnt have been quite so shocking - 90s/00s neolib economists thought China was shooting itself in the foot.

Re:We are all mercantilists now by AstralStorm on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @07:25AM (#44874882)
Actually they still are making that. And now advanced expensive stuff nowadays too.

After all, it's easier to further an already existing advantage.

Re:We are all mercantilists now by pydry on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @09:01AM (#44875715)
shrug and the theory of static comparative advantage said that by trying to move up the value chain they were shooting themselves in the foot.

It sounds stupid, but so do many intellectual fashions of a bygone era.

Re:We are all mercantilists now by numpad0 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @04:56AM (#44873969)
You guys(I'm not from US) are confused because you thought gaming economy and chasing global economic optima gives you everything, and it didn't quite do so. That's because economic theories don't consider purposes or political importances of a product, it'll tell you it's stupid to make your own nuclear missiles when you can get a bulk discount from China. And you're looking for a different framework that works better than that.

The USA was unique in that it was always outspoken with patriotism, and to lesser extent with classical nationalism than usual. Maybe the US is reaching some stage where it grows its own proper form of good-old ethnic nationalism, whether it's a good thing or not...

Re:We are all mercantilists now by legitster on Monday August 11, 2025 @12:34PM (#44866218)
> Smith wasn't right on everything, but he was right to criticize Mercantilism.

I don't know why there's a need to hedge. Smith's observations were incredibly objective and insightful and have aged extremely well.

There were areas where his observations were incomplete or refined later (absolute vs relative advantage, paradox of value, efficiency of corporations).

Even Karl Marx found little in Smith's work that was disagreeable.

The Wealth of Nations is a seminal piece of Western civilization and deserves all the respect we can bestow such works.

Re:We are all mercantilists now by js8 on Monday August 11, 2025 @04:11PM (#44868884)
Mark Blyth has some interesting critique of Adam Smith in https://youtu.be/JQuHSQXxsjM
Re:We are all mercantilists now by moomin on Monday August 11, 2025 @12:40PM (#44866300)
Adam Smith mostly has a lousy reputation these days because of the work of the Adam Smith Institute, which does not accurately reflect his thinking.
Re:We are all mercantilists now by lemonberry on Monday August 11, 2025 @01:25PM (#44866892)
Yes, it seems that a lot (most?) of contemporary proponents of capitalism have cherry picked from 'The Wealth of Nations' and completely ignored 'The Theory of Moral Sentiments'.
Re:We are all mercantilists now by Findeton on Monday August 11, 2025 @09:05PM (#44871228)
Yes, it was a very important book and set of ideas. But it also had some shortcomings. For example, he has a theory of value based on labor/work (and David Ricardo continued with that approach, and then Karl Marx as well). That is greatly improved by Carl Menger's marginal theory of value.
Re:We are all mercantilists now by js8 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @01:50AM (#44872836)
While I agree that labor theory of value is wrong, I believe that theory of value based on utility is even less descriptive of the real world (and in that sense a regress).

People are not utility calculating machines. I would say these utility theories (I would call them theories of subjective value) have several flaws:

1. There are some things that all sane humans objectively (universally) value (things like survival, not being harmed, time and energy expenditure).

2. Sometimes humans simply value things that other humans value, as a shortcut to expending energy in figuring out what to value.

3. Any reasonably good theory value has to incorporate incomplete information that people have, and thus might value something that is not valuable and vice versa due to lack of information.

Some of these lead to nonlinear behavior which is really not well captured by an additive theory such as marginal theory of value.

Re:We are all mercantilists now by AstralStorm on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @07:18AM (#44874834)
Don't worry, economists surely have their calculation of the day.

Previously it was ordinary differential equations. Now attempting to solve these is intractable for such a big and complex system so far, and worse if you misrepresented the model or approximated ot too much.

So essentially all the theories with an equation are a guess.

Doubly so for theories without an equation that are not tied to experimental data... (Hello Austrians)

Re:We are all mercantilists now by Findeton on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @09:23AM (#44875904)
I don't think you understand the marginal theory of value at all. Like, at all. Obviously the marginal theory of value does incorporate all your concerns.

First, because Menger, creator of the Austrian school of economics, uses methodological individualism. That means it includes the fact people have incomplete information and subjective value (for example based on what others value). These are points 2,3.

About point 1, you clearly don't understand marginalism. You value more water over gold, but a glass of water is cheaper than the same weight of gold. If you were thirsty and about to die in the middle of the desert, you'd pay up to infinite money for a glass of water and 0 for gold. But you value just the next marginal unit of water, not the first one, so you know you can have as many glasses of water as you want just by opening the tap. I'm sure in your lifetime you'll spend way more money on water/beverages than on gold, but a single glass of water is cheaper.