News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:PHP compile time generics: yay or nay? by fuzzy_biscuit on Sunday August 10, 2025 @07:41PM (#44859465)
I don't take issue with the naming but with the names that feel a bit beyond my ken. "Erased" makes sense when explained but not before. "Reified" is a word I simply do not use so it feels like academia run amok.

Regardless, I recognize myself as the point of failure, but those names do strike me as academia speak, though better than some/many. <shrug>

Re:PHP compile time generics: yay or nay? by klodolph on Sunday August 10, 2025 @09:23PM (#44859953)
Another shrug, but part of it is that the PL community (programming language community) is pretty deep into its own jargon that doesn’t have as much overlap as you might think, with other subfields of computer science.

People describe a type system as “not well-founded” or “unsound” and those are specific jabs at the axioms, and people talk about “system F” or “type erasure” or “reification”. Polymorphism can be “ad-hoc” or “parametric”, and type parameters can be invariant, covariant, and contravariant. It’s just a lot of jargon and I think the main reason it’s not intuitive to people outside the right fields is that the actual concepts are mostly unfamiliar.

Re:PHP compile time generics: yay or nay? by bawolff on Monday August 11, 2025 @01:12AM (#44860902)
> Another shrug, but part of it is that the PL community (programming language community) is pretty deep into its own jargon that doesn’t have as much overlap as you might think, with other subfields of computer science.

The word reified dates back to the 1800s. It isn't the most common word, but it also definitely wasn't invented by the programming language community.

Re:PHP compile time generics: yay or nay? by peterfirefly on Monday August 11, 2025 @09:28AM (#44863839)
It was (and is) used a lot by philosophers and there was a large overlap between a certain class of philosophers and a certain class of mathematicians who developed early type theory. Any type theorist who knows his literature will run into reification very early on.