Re:Try and
by interestica on Sunday August 10, 2025 @02:26PM
(#44857175)
> "Truly", we understand each other better and communicate faster ~when we out speech draws from a a collection of words~, idioms, and grammatical constructions familiar to the listener. This linguistic inventory is not natural. It must be taught. Errors must he corrected, not validated. Not every utterance from someone's mouth has equal merit.
It’s okay. I still understood you.
Re:Try and
by umanwizard on Sunday August 10, 2025 @07:12PM
(#44859230)
Sorry, but you are completely misunderstanding what “descriptivism” means, why it’s the viewpoint taken in serious linguistics, and how common it is there (i.e. absolutely 100% universal among everyone who studies language scientifically).
> absolutely 100% universal among everyone who studies language scientifically
They are all wrong.
Re:Try and
by umanwizard on Monday August 11, 2025 @08:27AM
(#44863417)
Well, why?
The point of science is to understand natural phenomena, not to pass value judgments on them. Biologists’ job is not to decide which out of dogs and cats is “correct”. Why should linguistics be any different?
Re:Try and
by bigstrat2003 on Monday August 11, 2025 @01:04AM
(#44860870)
Well said. Linguistic descriptivism is completely incoherent because it can't actually tell you anything. All a descriptivist can do is say "yep, you sure are using the word that way" which isn't remotely useful or interesting.
Re:Try and
by umanwizard on Monday August 11, 2025 @08:30AM
(#44863429)
Do you think any scientific inquiry in any field is useful or interesting?
Re:Try and
by giraffe_lady on Monday August 11, 2025 @12:09PM
(#44865882)
Important to note that no linguists hold this view and it is entirely outside the consensus mainstream of the discipline. This view is popular on HN but it is about as scientifically reputable as lysenkoism and not much more useful.
Re:Try and
by weregiraffe on Monday August 11, 2025 @05:30AM
(#44862328)
>when draw speech from a a collection of words, idioms, and grammatical constructions
And who will be the keepers (or should I say gate-keepers) of this glorious collection? And will they prevent Tolkien from spelling plural of dwarf as dwarves? Will they force Cormac McCarthy to use quotation marks?
Yes, there is. Linguistic descriptivism is a stale 1960s academic fad wrapped up in a revolutionary energy that's dead and cringe now. Like that era's other insane postmodernisms, it rejects reality and reality has rejected it right back.
"Truly", we understand each other better and communicate faster when draw speech from a a collection of words, idioms, and grammatical constructions familiar to the listener. This linguistic inventory is not natural. It must be taught. Errors must he corrected, not validated. Not every utterance from someone's mouth has equal merit.