News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by johnfn on Saturday August 09, 2025 @08:36PM (#44851732)
For some reason AI seems to bring out articles that seem to fundamentally lack curiosity - opting instead for gleeful mockery and scorn. I like AI, but I'll happily read thoughtful articles from people who disagree. But not this. This article has no value other than to dunk on the opposition.

I tend to think HN's moderation is OK, but I think these sorts of low-curiosity articles need to be off the front page.

Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by bko on Saturday August 09, 2025 @09:25PM (#44852013)
> For some reason AI seems to bring out articles that seem to fundamentally lack curiosity - opting instead for gleeful mockery and scorn

I think its broader to all tech. It all started in 2016 after it was deemed that tech, especially social media, had helped sway the election. Since then a lot of things became political that weren't in the past and tech got swept up w/ that. And unfortunately AI has its haters despite the fact that it's objectively the fastest growing most exciting technology in the last 50 years. Instead they're dissecting some CEOs shitposts.

Fast forward to today, pretty much everything is political. Take this banger from NY Times:

> Mr. Kennedy has singled out Froot Loops as an example of a product with too many ingredients. In an interview with MSNBC on Nov. 6, he questioned the overall ingredient count: “Why do we have Froot Loops in this country that have 18 or 19 ingredients and you go to Canada and it has two or three?” Mr. Kennedy asked.

> He was wrong on the ingredient count, they are roughly the same. But the Canadian version does have natural colorings made from blueberries and carrots while the U.S. product contains red dye 40, yellow 5 and blue 1 as well as Butylated hydroxytoluene, or BHT, a lab-made chemical that is used “for freshness,” according to the ingredient label.

No self-awareness.

https://archive.is/dT2qK#selection-975.0-996.0

Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by moritzwarhier on Saturday August 09, 2025 @10:52PM (#44852428)
I think you are missing the forest for the trees here.

> It all started in 2016 after it was deemed that tech, especially social media, had helped sway the election. Since then a lot of things became political that weren't in the past and tech got swept up w/ that

The 2016 election was a symptom of broader societal changes, and yeah, I'd also say it exhibited a new level of psychological manipulation in election campaigns. But the election being "deemed" influenced by technology and media (sure it was, why not?) as a cause for political division seems very far-fetched. Regarding the US healthcare politics farce, I don't understand your point or how it relates to the beginning of your comment.

Political division and propaganda inciting outrage are flourishing, yes. Not because of what you describe about the 2016 election though, IMO. What's the connection? So you mean if nobody had assessed social media campaigns after that election, politics wozld be more honest and fact-based? Why? And what did you want to say with the NY Times article about the US secretary of health and American junk food / cereals?

Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by bamboozled on Saturday August 09, 2025 @11:07PM (#44852492)
Political division and propaganda inciting outrage are flourishing, yes.

My concern is there is no antidote for this in the horizon it’s just more and more stupid getting traction all the time. You have to put a lot of faith in common sense to stay optimistic.

Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by moritzwarhier on Saturday August 09, 2025 @11:12PM (#44852503)
I agree with this, Neil Postmans "Amusing ourselves to death" is still a good read in 2025.

The only antidotes I can imagine are honesty and real community: make whatever you want from this, it should be obvious by now that global cut-throat capitalism does not lead to democracy, or to efficient resource usage (externalization...), or to equality.

Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by bamboozled on Sunday August 10, 2025 @10:22AM (#44855382)
Honestly my concern is WW3 fueled on propaganda. The ONLY reason I think this might not happen is because people are too amused to even bother fighting a war now. I'm not joking.
Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by hckrfucrs on Saturday August 09, 2025 @10:59PM (#44852455)
Exactly!

I mean, what's political about having former NSA heads on your "exciting technology" board?

Or what's political about lining up together as the front row at the despot in chief's inauguration?

And what's so political about lobbying to and sequestering large amounts of public funds for your personal manufactured consent machine?

These things are literally software that runs on technology developed in the last 50 years, but by your clearly apolitical, unbiased, absolutely thoughtful, well reasoned, fully researched, insight is in fact "the most exciting technology in the last 50 years".

Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by hitarpetar on Sunday August 10, 2025 @07:49AM (#44854564)
> objectively the fastest growing most exciting technology in the last 50 years

what's objective about this opinion? how does one objectively measure how exciting a technology is?

Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by BlueTemplar on Monday August 11, 2025 @02:15AM (#44861188)
The Snowden scandal ? Cambridge Analytica ? YouTube's ContentId in 2009 ? Microsoft's behaviour with IE ?

A lot of these issues are not general to infocoms either, but specific to platforms, to USian (/Russian/Chinese) companies, to companies grown too big and a failure of antitrust...

Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by WhyOhWhyQ on Monday August 11, 2025 @07:13AM (#44862913)
Why should the excitement of a technology have anything to do with my critical view of it? Are we toddlers playing with toys, or are we trying to make a better world here?
Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by ants_everywhere on Saturday August 09, 2025 @10:08PM (#44852232)
> opting instead for gleeful mockery and scorn.

People underestimate how much astroturfing there is in the anti-AI movement.

You can track the small number of anti-AI sentiments that crop up here and elsewhere. They map onto old anti technology arguements. And the people advancing them often show up in waves.

A lot of times people will hang out on Discord or Telegram and decide which comments sections to raid. Sometimes a raid starts after an article falls off the front page and suddenly there's a spike of interest from people on an obscure article where all the new people have exactly the same opinion.

Bloggers can confuse this sort astroturfing with real grass roots and end up writing for an audience who doesn't care at all about the quality of the content, only that it advances their message.

Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by mcswell on Saturday August 09, 2025 @10:32PM (#44852330)
But Marcus is decidedly NOT anti-AI, he's just against the idea that LLMs are the be-all end-all of AI. He may be right about that, or he may be wrong, but describing him as anti-AI is just wrong.
Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by ants_everywhere on Saturday August 09, 2025 @10:41PM (#44852369)
What I'm saying is it's easy for folks like him to fall into the trap of writing for an undiscriminating audience because their feedback is so positive and strong.

He was (and I think still is) a believer in psychological nativism, which I think is an intellectual dead end. You can't really believe in LLMs while also being a nativist.

But nobody really cares about the axe he's grinding (nativism), yet when he writes about the "slopocalypse" he gets positive feedback.

Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by MBCook on Saturday August 09, 2025 @10:13PM (#44852252)
So everyone who isn’t pro AI is just an astroturfer in a coordinated campaign?

I find that extremely unlikely.

Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by ants_everywhere on Saturday August 09, 2025 @10:18PM (#44852278)
Do you see how you've chosen to try to twist what I've said instead of honestly engaging with it?
Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by jfengel on Saturday August 09, 2025 @10:35PM (#44852346)
That was what it sounded like to me, too. I see another comment express the same.

I trust that wasn't what was intended but I'm not entirely sure what you did intend. So it's a little hard to engage with it.

Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by ants_everywhere on Saturday August 09, 2025 @10:50PM (#44852418)
Is there any single sentence in my comment that you think is factually incorrect as written?

And do you not see that it's a common form of intellectual dishonesty to pretend that a "there exists" statement is a "for all" statement, and now three people have tried to do this without adding anything at all to the discussion?

Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by hckrfucrs on Saturday August 09, 2025 @11:05PM (#44852481)
> Is there any single sentence in my comment that you think is factually incorrect as written?

I'll bite.

> You can track the small number of anti-AI sentiments that crop up here and elsewhere.

You say you can track. So, show me this "tracking".

Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by ants_everywhere on Sunday August 10, 2025 @02:24PM (#44857165)
Just copy the arguments you see a lot into a spreadsheet and track them.

There are fewer than 10 that come up repeatedly it's not hard to do.

Ones I see on HN frequently are the "slop" critique, the claim that AI produces inferior content, and the claim that customers hate it and it's being forced on them. These all go back at least to the luddite movement and have been used in every anti-tech movement I've looked into. I'm sure you're capable of tracking the other talking points.

There are other ones that don't go back to the luddites but which are nonsensical, like the critique that LLMs are statistical.

Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by MBCook on Saturday August 09, 2025 @11:02PM (#44852469)
You said people underestimate the amount of astroturfing. Clearly implying there is more than people think.

You seemed to imply there was a small amount of genuine anti-AI posting.

You then said the posts came in identifiable waves followed by explaining how people organize on discord to post such things.

All of that added up sounds to me like you are implying the vast majority of anti-AI sentiment is organized astroturfing. Yeah you never said every single one, I generalized on that front.

You say that’s not what you meant. Sorry, that was how I read your post. It sounded to me like a blatant dismissal of all critiques as fake or insincere.

Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by ants_everywhere on Sunday August 10, 2025 @02:14PM (#44857102)
People tend to think everything is organic. Whereas in reality there are forums and channels dedicated to raiding parties. And that's just the human participants, not including any bot activity or troll farm activity that's coordinated off of public forums.

That does not mean that all content is inorganic. In any culture war or wedge issue or agitprop campaign you seed with influencers and rely on amplification by ordinary people. But the influencers frame the debate, decide what the priorities are, etc.

It takes time and money to coordinate everyone's opinion on something. The natural tendency is toward entropy and fighting against that requires resources. So when large numbers of people believe the same thing and repeat the same lines that's a candidate for inorganic content. You can then investigate that further and decide whether it's a conlincidence or not.

Sometimes there's just a trend that catches on. But people also underestimate how much work and coordination goes into making something catch on.

This is a big part of why influencers and advertisers try to avoid the impression that they are paid to pretend to like something and why there are regulations requiring that you disclose paid content. People are easily fooled into thinking it's all just happening naturally and serendipitously.

Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by vaenaes on Saturday August 09, 2025 @10:15PM (#44852261)
Everyone that disagrees with me is paid to.
Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by ants_everywhere on Saturday August 09, 2025 @10:18PM (#44852280)
Do you see how you've chosen to try to twist what I've said instead of honestly engaging with it?
Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by RugnirViking on Sunday August 10, 2025 @05:57AM (#44854062)
This seems wrong -- i mean its certainly possible that such things happen, but anecdotally, most of my friends, university educated, are various shades of anti ai, especially those in artistic, writing, humanities, and musical fields. I'm not that anti ai myself and have discussed the issue with them at length
Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by hyperadvanced on Saturday August 09, 2025 @09:09PM (#44851928)
I don’t like AI and I think this type of article is very boring. Imagine having one of the most interesting technological developments of the last 50 years unfolding before your eyes and resort to reposting tweet fragments…
Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by hckrfucrs on Saturday August 09, 2025 @10:50PM (#44852420)
Ah yes, the highest form of curiosity, the kind that attempts to silence those whose opinion differs from your own.

If it hurts your feelings to have your terrible opinions "dunked" on then take the time to form better opinions.

Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by johnfn on Sunday August 10, 2025 @03:06PM (#44857432)
I said clearly and explicitly in my comment that I am happy to read thoughtful anti-AI material. That you disregarded this to write your comment says more about your ability to "form better opinions" than mine.
Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by giantrobot on Saturday August 09, 2025 @09:03PM (#44851911)
> opting instead for gleeful mockery and scorn

This is well earned by the likes of OpenAI that is trying to convince everyone they need trillions of dollars to build fabs to build super genius AIs. These super genius AIs will replace everyone (except billionaires) and act as magic money printers (for billionaires).

Meanwhile their super genius precursor AIs make up shit and can't count letters in words while being laughably sycophantic.

There's no need to defend poor innocent megacorps trying to usher in a techno-feudal dystopia.

Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by MBCook on Saturday August 09, 2025 @10:14PM (#44852257)
I think there’s plenty to mock about the hype around AI

That doesn’t mean any article mocking it or trashing it is well written or insightful.

Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by frozenseven on Saturday August 09, 2025 @10:21PM (#44852292)
>can't count letters in words

This really hasn't been a thing since reasoning models showed up. Any recent example of such seems to come from non-reasoning variants.

>laughably sycophantic

Mainstream models are moving away from this, afaik. Part of the recent drama is that GPT-5 wasn't sycophantic enough for some users.

Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by jjani on Sunday August 10, 2025 @01:26AM (#44852965)
Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by frozenseven on Sunday August 10, 2025 @04:38AM (#44853765)
This is exactly what I'm talking about. The immediate issue with GPT-5's launch was that some people were getting rerouted to 4o, and there was no control over which version of GPT-5 you're getting. Whatever he's talking to there looks nothing like a reasoning model.
Re:GPT-5: Overdue, overhyped and underwhelming. And that's n... by jepson19 on Sunday August 10, 2025 @01:58PM (#44856974)
I think this is the fundamental trend of all "commentary" in the digital age.

Thoughtful, nuanced takes simply cannot generate the same audience and velocity, and by the time you write something of actual substance the moment is gone and the hyper-narrative has moved on.