News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We replaced passwords with something worse by brettgriffin on Thursday August 07, 2025 @04:05PM (#44829677)
> BAD uses code to login to GOOD’s website as the user. BAD now has full access to the user’s GOOD account.

This doesn't work. The OTP only works when paired with a key on the browser that initiated the request.

Example: Go to claude.ai and click Continue with Email. Copy the link from the email and open it in a new browser.

> However, if some popular email service suddenly decides your login emails or the login link within should be blocked, then suddenly many of your users cannot login.

This might be the only case against emailed OTPs but I don't think there is enough data to show it actually has merit.

Re:We replaced passwords with something worse by kam on Thursday August 07, 2025 @04:18PM (#44829831)
The browser that initiated the request is under the control of BAD in step 3.
Re:We replaced passwords with something worse by brettgriffin on Thursday August 07, 2025 @04:28PM (#44829917)
ah, you are correct. thanks for pointing that out.