Re:Skeuomorphism is the easy way out
by thebigpicture on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @10:34PM
(#4482602)
What you find ambiguous may not align with what others find ambiguous. You, as a nerd, know there are many options that "save" could entail. Does everyone else know that?
What if a user has no idea about "save options". To them "save" might just mean "save". That is, they want to be able to retrieve it later.
If I say to you "Jump!", you might ask "How high?" Others might just jump. Should we enlist some participants in a study and see what most people do? Let's ask people what "save" means. Then let's show them a button and ask them what it means.
Why does some software have an option to "show button text"?
Why would anyone want to see text on a button? Why would anyone want that?
I wish there was a way I could post to HN in a series of buttons, like hieroglyphics. It would be "way better" than using words. You could click on them and they would bounce up and down. Way better than reading.
What if a user has no idea about "save options". To them "save" might just mean "save". That is, they want to be able to retrieve it later.
If I say to you "Jump!", you might ask "How high?" Others might just jump. Should we enlist some participants in a study and see what most people do? Let's ask people what "save" means. Then let's show them a button and ask them what it means.
Why does some software have an option to "show button text"? Why would anyone want to see text on a button? Why would anyone want that?
I wish there was a way I could post to HN in a series of buttons, like hieroglyphics. It would be "way better" than using words. You could click on them and they would bounce up and down. Way better than reading.