News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:19% of California houses are owned by investors by grafmax on Wednesday August 06, 2025 @04:21PM (#44817276)
And yet 20% of the market being captured by those who already have a home, while so many go without one, indicates a shortcoming in our society’s ability to distribute resources from those who don’t need them to those who do.
Re:19% of California houses are owned by investors by tptacek on Wednesday August 06, 2025 @07:34PM (#44819078)
Renting a home out isn't "capturing" the house. Rental housing is a desirable product. Lots of people don't want to own, be locked into a particular house for years to offset transaction costs, and to own all the downside and maintenance risk of the property.
Re:19% of California houses are owned by investors by cloverich on Thursday August 07, 2025 @12:16AM (#44820516)
Consider soliciting the opinion of more renters. Plenty of us would happily purchase if prices were more reasonable. Renting out sfh should be rare, imho. The current situation needs many remedies and kicking out sfh as investment vehicles is a very low hanging fruit.
Re:19% of California houses are owned by investors by kasey_junk on Thursday August 07, 2025 @03:12AM (#44821488)
Kicking out sfh as investment vehicles makes it harder to sell homes. This a) increases the risk to home buyers and b) makes owning inventory more expensive. Thats likely to make increasing supply untenable.

This low hanging “remedy” is likely to exacerbate the supply issue, not help it.

Re:19% of California houses are owned by investors by cloverich on Thursday August 07, 2025 @10:22AM (#44824824)
Demand would still outstrip supply, so by what mechanism would selling be difficult or risky? It would modestly reduce prices, making it less expensive for all regular home owners. That's a win for everyone but (sfh) investors.
Re:19% of California houses are owned by investors by kasey_junk on Thursday August 07, 2025 @10:42AM (#44825114)
Home builders are “investors” in sfh. So out of the gate you’ve got a problem with making the regulations more complicated to navigate. For the people creating supply.

Some of those homebuilders build because they can rent homes if they can’t be sold. Others build because they have large investors to sell to if necessary. All of them build with their financial models account for carry time, as carry costs are extremely important to their bottom line.

If the average carry time goes up even a little bit (and it will because investors close faster) that can make whole developments untenable.

Re:19% of California houses are owned by investors by cloverich on Thursday August 07, 2025 @11:40AM (#44825936)
> So out of the gate you’ve got a problem with making the regulations more complicated to navigate.

Assuming the policy to reduce non-primary home ownership is tax based, carve out tax exceptions for home builders. Personally I would carve out exceptions for home flippers too, but could see that being more contentious. Either way though, this part of the problem would be, IMHO, trivial to solve.

> If the average carry time goes up even a little bit (and it will because investors close faster) that can make whole developments untenable. Others build because they have large investors to sell to if necessary.

I think that's fair. But conversely carry time is also high because prices are high, and investors drive up prices; builders also do this to an extent, by e.g. buying down points to avoid lowering prices, to keep the perceived price elevated. I have no illusions this is a simple problem to solve. The right question here is probably figuring out whether the overall supply going up by X increased rate because of investors will be worth the cost of the total homeownership rate being controlled by a shrinking proportion of the population (I would guess no).

My personal proposed solution here would be to kick out investors (tax policy), and also directly incentivize home builders selling to first time owners (via tax credits, comparable to e.g. EV tax credits). The latter would be quite expensive, but if the overall homeownership rate increases and home prices drop, it would likely be popular.

Re:19% of California houses are owned by investors by tptacek on Thursday August 07, 2025 @11:54AM (#44826141)
Tax incentives for first-time home buyers are enormously regressive. You're operating from a presumption that everybody intends to buy a house (see upthread), but that's not true, and it gets less true as you go down the income ladder. Owning a home comes with huge downside risk, added expense, and loss of flexibility.
Re:19% of California houses are owned by investors by kasey_junk on Thursday August 07, 2025 @12:52PM (#44826906)
Homeownership rates are not particularly out of band right now. They’ve kept within a couple of % points for the entire post ww2 era. They’ve kept within track almost exactly mortgage rates. They are higher they were 10 years ago for instance.

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/RHORUSQ156N

But note that’s not the same thing as housing affordability. You probably can goose the homeownership rate by appropriating a bunch of homes and redistributing them to the marginal buyers who are currently not owners.

But it will not drop the price of housing, it will increase it because supply will still be constrained (think of the normal case of someone moving temporarily for work. If you disincentivize them being allowed to rent the unit out you now have 2 units off the market).

Carry cost is mostly about financing costs and regulations not the price of homes.

Re:19% of California houses are owned by investors by tptacek on Thursday August 07, 2025 @08:54AM (#44823871)
Spoken like someone who never lost their shirt on a house after discovering they had to move a couple years after buying. No, I'm pretty confident: lots of renters are renters on purpose. Ownership is not categorically better than renting.
Re:19% of California houses are owned by investors by bpt3 on Wednesday August 06, 2025 @05:05PM (#44817841)
20% of CA residents are homeless? Citation please!
Re:19% of California houses are owned by investors by esseph on Wednesday August 06, 2025 @07:22PM (#44818994)
That's not at all what they said.
Re:19% of California houses are owned by investors by bpt3 on Wednesday August 06, 2025 @08:37PM (#44819447)
To spell it out, they seem to be completely ignoring that those rental properties are not vacant. Instead, they house people, just like they would if they were owner occupied.
Re:19% of California houses are owned by investors by esseph on Wednesday August 06, 2025 @09:52PM (#44819802)
20% of market capture does not cause homelessness, but there are many very valid arguments that treating housing as an investment isn't a stairway to ending homelessness.
Re:19% of California houses are owned by investors by bpt3 on Wednesday August 06, 2025 @11:31PM (#44820304)
> 20% of market capture does not cause homelessness

Right, which is why trying to link the two is misleading at best.

> there are many valid arguments that treating housing as an investment isn't a stairway to ending homelessness

Such as? We seem to agree that the existence of rental units isn't a cause of homelessness.

Re:19% of California houses are owned by investors by esseph on Thursday August 07, 2025 @12:00AM (#44820447)
Turbo Greed (acquire all the things) and lack of monopoly protection and enforcement.

If we're going to tackle homeless, we have to remove systems that incentivize the collection of homes as a financial asset. Make more homes by one person or entity less desirable or simply undoable.

Re:19% of California houses are owned by investors by bpt3 on Thursday August 07, 2025 @07:24AM (#44823121)
Turbo greed isn't a thing. And if you think there's a monopoly in residential real estate ownership, you have an absurdly broad definition of the term.

Instead of trying to manipulate a market through yet another layer of regulation, you can just let builders build more.

Re:19% of California houses are owned by investors by esseph on Thursday August 07, 2025 @11:45AM (#44826014)
If turbo Greed isn't a thing, why do the 830+ billionaires in the United States control more wealth than the bottom 50% of the population?

And, why did we just give them a YUGE tax break?

"Build more" is not an option, because the incentives don't align to solve the problem. The things getting built are built to capture margins and not to solve the housing problem.

Need regulation.

Re:19% of California houses are owned by investors by bpt3 on Thursday August 07, 2025 @02:09PM (#44828201)
You're missing the point, which is that adding a superlative in front of a concept you don't like doesn't make it more important or the problem more severe. And your reductionist take on wealth distribution isn't even worth discussing.

Build more is the only option to actually fix the problem. The incentives could not be more aligned between home builders and home dwellers. Builders want to build, and there are dozens of them in all major metropolitan areas. Home dwellers want shelter. Sounds like an ideal situation to keep margins low.

More regulation == more regulatory capture, which your kind supposedly doesn't like but you don't seem to be able to help yourself.

Re:19% of California houses are owned by investors by esseph on Thursday August 07, 2025 @02:29PM (#44828493)
I don't know what the fuck "my kind" is, but you instantly threw away any validity you may have remotely had by jumping to some nonsense like that.

I'm not "missing the point" because I don't agree with economic principles that got us where we are today. Doubling down on those very same principles thinking we will have a different outcome? Nonsense.

Re:19% of California houses are owned by investors by bpt3 on Thursday August 07, 2025 @02:58PM (#44828870)
"Your kind" are the type of people who use terms like "turbo greed" and expect to have their opinions taken seriously.

It's not a coincidence that there's a huge overlap between people who use terms like "turbo greed", those who "don't agree" with the economic principles that have outperformed all known alternatives, and those who think that more state involvement is the solution to every problem.

Re:19% of California houses are owned by investors by esseph on Thursday August 07, 2025 @10:07PM (#44832674)
Say "your kind" one more fucking time. You claim to know my kind.
Re:19% of California houses are owned by investors by bpt3 on Friday August 08, 2025 @01:20PM (#44839460)
Your kind also tends to be driven more by emotional response and feelings than objective measurements.
Re:19% of California houses are owned by investors by esseph on Friday August 08, 2025 @01:59PM (#44839791)
Thank you for proving exactly who I thought you were.
Re:19% of California houses are owned by investors by bpt3 on Friday August 08, 2025 @04:05PM (#44841110)
Which is?