News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by jonny_eh on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @05:45PM (#4481625)
A great example of moving the goal post.

Go down the list, as each on is stricken off the supporters will say "it was never about X, it was always about Y".

I'm constantly hearing about how organic food is: Healthier, tastier, or better for the environment. The scientific literature just doesn't hold up with any of those claims. [1]

On top of that, if there was some aspect of organic food that actually did make it better for the environment, then let's just use that with normal farming. Why create an arbitrary new category of food based on a fallacy? [2]

[1] http://theness.com/neurologicablog/index.php/organic-food-pe...

[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appeal_to_nature

Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by smartician on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @06:17PM (#4481778)
It's not moving the goalpost, it's pointing out a straw man fallacy. "Organic" just means that (among other things) no synthetic fertilizers, irradiation, sewage sludge or genetic engineering was used. I'm not sure who seriously expects that food produced like this would be "more nutritious", but it's proven that organic food contains less contaminants than conventional food [1]. Also, the studies mentioned probably only observe a few well-known micro-nutrients like vitamins. But I read somewhere that an apple for example contains more than a hundred organic compounds, the effects of which we haven't fully researched yet (ever heard of ursolic acid for example? [2]). Some studies showed that organic chicken and eggs contain more Omega 3 fatty acids.

The organic label is also an indicator that the production process is not as low-cost as possible, and usually high quality and low price are opposing goals. This is not necessarily always the case, but as I said it's an indicator.

[1] http://www.guardian.co.uk/science/2012/sep/04/organic-foods-...

[2] http://www.naturalnews.com/036312_apple_peel_obesity_ursolic...

Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by derleth on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @07:09PM (#4481991)
> no synthetic fertilizers, irradiation, sewage sludge or genetic engineering was used

Never mind that each of those things have greatly different effects on the safety of the food and other things:

> no synthetic fertilizers

A valid environmental concern, depending on how the fertilizers are used and where the runoff goes.

> irradiation

Fear-mongering nonsense. Irradiation doesn't make food radioactive. It just kills what's growing on the food without noxious chemicals.

> sewage sludge

A slam. Nobody literally uses sewage sludge to grow food, unless you're talking about nightsoil (human excrement used as fertilizer), which is entirely organic.

> genetic engineering

More fear-mongering nonsense when applied to food safety, but a valid concern as regards patent law and similar legal battles.

Also, citing to Natural News is bad. They're the ones who claim Bill Gates wants to depopulate the world using vaccines, which they also believe are evil.

Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by smartician on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @07:38PM (#4482079)
All these additives and processes seem to be reasonably safe given what we currently believe to know, but that doesn't mean that there aren't any yet unknown side effects. Centuries ago we used to line tin cans with lead, used mercury to cure leather and tried to treat various illnesses with mega doses of radiation. All those things seemed perfectly safe at the time, but today they are unthinkable.
Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by enraged_camel on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @07:51PM (#4482119)
>>All these additives and processes seem to be reasonably safe given what we currently believe to know, but that doesn't mean that there aren't any yet unknown side effects.

Should we also avoid ice cream because for all we know, it may have unintended side effects?

Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by smartician on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @09:23PM (#4482405)
Right, because freezing something is totally comparable to using radiation or anorganic chemicals.

Or are you referring to questionable stuff in ice cream like carrageenan?

Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by derleth on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @10:07PM (#4482512)
You're not getting it. You are throwing out all of these unfounded accusations not based on anything at all and you still expect us to take you seriously. You're engaging in fear-mongering and we're calling you on it.

> using radiation or anorganic chemicals.

This is fear-mongering unless you can actually point to reasonable problems such things might cause.

> questionable stuff in ice cream like carrageenan

Carrageenan is fine when used in the way the regulations dictate. Or do you have actual evidence otherwise?

Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by smartician on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @10:37PM (#4482613)
I think you have it backwards. Being cautious is not fear-mongering. Do I think anything FDA approved will kill me directly? No. But I think the testing protocol is flawed. As far as I know, long term effect safety studies are only done on animal models. And the benchmark is always illness or disease, not optimal health. Nobody can ask a rat how it feels. And then there's the issue of synergistic effects. The FDA only studies substances in isolation, but there might be adverse effects that only occur if a substance reacts with another substance or process.

So, in short, if I can choose between a product that is "natural" or a product that has mystery substance X in it, I'd choose the natural one, even if it means I have to pay a little more. I'd also prefer it that product B is labelled in a way that I can tell it contains mystery substance X, so that I can make that decision. Is that fear-mongering? I don't think so.

Oh, and regarding carrageenan: It's not evidence, but I have personal experience that it makes my skin flare up, both when I ingest it and when I use it topically (shampoo for example). I later found out that the same stuff is used to provoke inflammation in animal experiments [1]. Do I still eat it from time to time? Yes, Ben & Jerry's is too delicious. But I feel better when I eat Haagen Dasz "5", which has none of the funky stuff.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carrageenan#Food_and_other_dome...

Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by enraged_camel on Thursday September 06, 2012 @12:13PM (#4484810)
>>As far as I know, long term effect safety studies are only done on animal models. And the benchmark is always illness or disease, not optimal health.

We know for a fact that ice cream is bad for "optimal health." It can cause tooth cavities, sore throat, stomach aches, obesity and diabetes. Yet we still eat it because it tastes good.

Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by derleth on Thursday September 06, 2012 @02:16AM (#4483041)
> But I think the testing protocol is flawed. As far as I know, long term effect safety studies are only done on animal models. And the benchmark is always illness or disease, not optimal health. Nobody can ask a rat how it feels. And then there's the issue of synergistic effects. The FDA only studies substances in isolation, but there might be adverse effects that only occur if a substance reacts with another substance or process.

All of this does sound rational, but without any specific reasons to be concerned it's pointless to spin stories like this. Why? Because we can say the same stuff about anything else on Earth. Singling out some foods and food components for this treatment is illogical.

> if I can choose between a product that is "natural" or a product that has mystery substance X in it, I'd choose the natural one

Carrageenan is not a mystery. It is to you, sure, because you don't educate yourself very well, but it isn't a mystery to the rest of us.

> I'd also prefer it that product B is labelled in a way that I can tell it contains mystery substance X

I'd like it if 'dietary supplements' were held to the same standards as the actual medicines they're advertised as being able to replace, but that hasn't happened.

And you're wrong: Foods have ingredients lists. Carrageenan is one of the things they have to mention. Ah, but that only applies to processed foods, and not 'natural' foods, where you don't know what they contain.

> I have personal experience that it makes my skin flare up, both when I ingest it and when I use it topically (shampoo for example).

Really. Assuming you're not lying or mistaken, you're one of a very, very small number of people who has a bad reaction to carrageenan in those products.

> I feel better when I eat Haagen Dasz "5", which has none of the funky stuff.

Probably because you know it doesn't contain (what you consider to be) funky stuff.

How about this: There are people who think casein, a protein naturally found in milk, is toxic to humans. How would you convince one of those people that consuming casein is not a problem, if one of them tried to talk you out of eating ice cream?

Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by jaggederest on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @08:22PM (#4482233)
> Also, citing to Natural News is bad. They're the ones who [...]

That's a fallacy. A very classic ad hominem - pointing out something entirely unrelated that they believe, to discredit their statements on other matters.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ad_hominem

Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by jonny_eh on Thursday September 06, 2012 @12:39PM (#4484966)
Natural News are just an awful web site. I would tend to believe the opposite of whatever non-sense they're pushing.
Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by derleth on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @08:26PM (#4482251)
> entirely unrelated

It is completely related. In fact, it goes to the very heart of the matter: They publish nonsense about health issues, and we're discussing a health issue!

Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by inafield on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @07:22PM (#4482029)
> Fear-mongering nonsense. Irradiation doesn't make food radioactive. It just kills what's growing on the food without noxious chemicals.

Is that all they're doing? They said something similar about dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane (DDT).

> A slam. Nobody literally uses sewage sludge to grow food, unless you're talking about nightsoil (human excrement used as fertilizer), which is entirely organic.

Some farms do use untreated sewage sludge to grow food. As for human excrement, the chemical and bacterial content is very different depending on the diet of the humans in question.

> genetic engineering

We don't yet know all the side effects of genetic engineering. We also don't know what has been hidden or destroyed by corporations that want to hide the 2% mutant plant that ate the research team. I'm being funny and exaggerative, but we really don't know.

Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by falcolas on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @07:36PM (#4482074)
>> Fear-mongering nonsense. Irradiation doesn't make food radioactive. It just kills what's growing on the food without noxious chemicals. > Is that all they're doing? They said something similar about dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane (DDT).

Might not want to open your mail then. Some of it is irradiated to kill bacteria and viruses, based on origin and destination. Probably don't want to use bandaids, either, since they are irradiated to steralize them.

> Some farms do use untreated sewage sludge to grow food. As for human excrement, the chemical and bacterial content is very different depending on the diet of the humans in question.

Whose sewage? Human is dangerous, due to the fact that human pathogens can carry over from one incarnation to the next. Livestock, not so much; and is commonly used in "organic" fertilizers.

Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by derleth on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @08:07PM (#4482176)
> They said something similar about dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane (DDT).

Ooooh scary letters.

To be clear: DDT is not very toxic to humans. The reason we stopped using it was because it was becoming not very toxic to mosquitoes, as well, as they evolved resistance, in addition to what it was doing to birds. We still use DDT in regions where malaria is most dangerous.

http://www.pan-uk.org/pestnews/Actives/ddt.htm

> In one study involving humans, 17 people ate 35 mg/man daily (about 0.5 mg/kg daily) for 18 months suffering no ill-effect(25). In another study volunteers ate 0.31 to 0.61 mg/kg daily without any noticeable effects(26).

http://www.blackwellpublishing.com/ridley/tutorials/The_theo...

> DDT-resistant mosquitoes were first detected in India in 1959, and they have increased so rapidly that when a local spray program is begun now, most mosquitoes become resistant in a matter of months rather than years.

Also:

> We also don't know what has been hidden or destroyed by corporations

Without any evidence, this is fear-mongering. This is what fear-mongering is. Using rumors and innuendo to make people afraid without saying anything of substance.

Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by inafield on Monday September 10, 2012 @01:13PM (#4500835)
You are being mocking and misunderstanding my intent. A proper scientific approach would independently and fully evaluate the effects rather than assuming it is "ok". That is not fear-mongering, it is good scientific process that requires a unbiased oversight.

Is the issue potentially slight? Yes. Is it still an issue? Yes.

Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by stinkytaco on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @05:57PM (#4481687)
I don't think you're being fair calling it a "moving goalpost". The "organic movement", if that's even a thing, is about a lot of things to lots of different people. It's about supporting local economies, safety and jobs for field workers, a reaction to the decline of rural culture and the rise of agribusiness, getting more fruits and vegetables and less corn byproducts into children, etc. It's also a movement with a long history and lots of different players pushing different agendas, co-opting a single word to relay their message.

It's like reading an article in Wired called "The Rise of the Geeks" or "Silicon Valley Rebels" depending on the time and context it could mean 1,000 different things.

When someone says "organic" they could mean "organic" in the sense the USDA means it, or the could mean: biodynamic, local, home grown, etc.

Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by derleth on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @07:02PM (#4481965)
> more fruits and vegetables and less corn byproducts

Wow. What on earth do you think corn even is? Monsanto didn't invent the stuff, you know.

Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by xionon on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @07:17PM (#4482012)
Based on context, I think it's clear that stinkytaco was talking about things like high-fructose corn syrup and corn chips and corn-based cereals, as "corn byproducts," opposed to unprocessed vegetables and fruits.

If we're being pedantic, though, corn is a grain, not a vegetable (probably).[1] But that's clearly not what you meant, so it's not really worth digging into.

[1]http://empirezone.blogs.nytimes.com/2007/06/11/corn-vegetabl...

Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by derleth on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @08:16PM (#4482208)
> high-fructose corn syrup and corn chips and corn-based cereals

These are bad to the extent they're calorie-dense and nutrient-poor, which most First-Worlders don't need. They're like honey in that respect. Corn isn't the problem.

Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by prodigal_erik on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @11:30PM (#4482724)
There's been speculation about whether fructose and glucose have differing effects on satiety and insulin resistance, but the studies I've seen were conflicting. I assume it's possible to make high-fructose syrup out of other starches, and corn is only associated because it's cheap and commonly used.
Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by inafield on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @07:13PM (#4481997)
Paraphrasing: Depending on the specific type of corn, Monsanto would disagree with you.
Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by derleth on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @08:17PM (#4482213)
That's a legal-political problem, as I mentioned elsethread.
Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by lansing on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @07:16PM (#4482009)
Corn is a grain, not a fruit or a vegetable.
Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by mc32 on Thursday September 06, 2012 @01:48AM (#4482989)
Well, fortunately, corn is technically (botanically) a fruit. A dry fruit consisting of one fused seed.
Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by jamesbritt on Thursday September 06, 2012 @01:13PM (#4485136)
I used to think the "tomato: fruit of vegetable?" question was the big amusing food debate, but now I found this: http://empirezone.blogs.nytimes.com/2007/06/11/corn-vegetabl...
Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by mc32 on Thursday September 06, 2012 @06:09PM (#4486539)
Well, there is the botanical pov and the culinary pov. From a culinary pov, corn is mostly a veg. but there are exceptions like the grain (dry fruit) for popcorn.
Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by slantyyz on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @05:47PM (#4481641)
>> Why create an arbitrary new category of food based on a fallacy?

I thought organic food was bringing back an old category of food that just happened to have a new name. Just like how people like to add the word "artisanal" to foods. It's a newish word (marketing wise) to describe doing things the old way.

Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by r00fus on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @06:59PM (#4481948)
> I thought organic food was bringing back an old category of food that just happened to have a new name.

It's an quality standards certification [1]. Part of it is "doing things the old fashioned way" but that's mainly a reaction to the negatives of big-agribusiness over-use of irradiation and pesticides... as new way of meeting organic requirements are found, as long as the quality standard is met, it's still organic.

That's not to say the term "organic" hasn't been co-opted, much like "green", or "hybrid" [2]

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Organic_certification [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greenwashing

Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by derleth on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @08:18PM (#4482221)
> over-use of irradiation

Just curious, what are the downsides of over-use of irradiation? Be as specific as you can, please.

Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by MartinCron on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @08:05PM (#4482170)
I prefer the notion of labeling adulterated foods as "imitation", so when you go to the grocery store, you'll see things like "imitation" bread, cheese, etc.
Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by jonny_eh on Thursday September 06, 2012 @12:43PM (#4484992)
Farming has been evolving for thousands of years. There is no "old way".
Re:Organic Food Isn't More Nutritious, but That Isn't the Point by varelse on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @05:52PM (#4481664)
[2] Just try to get agro-business to accept lower yields on poultry and livestock in exchange for halting the use of antibiotics in their feed. Good luck with that one. Doesn't seem like an appeal to nature whatsoever - it just seems like a practice that should be considered harmful.

But beyond my belief that produce and livestock that have been bred for flavor instead of yield/shelf-life taste better, and that the same people doing the former tend to farm organic in my biased experience, we're otherwise in agreement.