News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI is not Making Engineers 10x as Productive by TrackerFF on Tuesday August 05, 2025 @12:45PM (#44800474)
Say you want to create a web app, but you don't know any web dev. You spend a couple of months reading front-end and back-end dev, incrementally create something, and after half a year you've made a web app you like. Say you spent 4 hours a day, 5 days a week, for 6 weeks, going from zero to a functional web app. So you spent 120 hours in total.

Now let's say you use Claude code, or whatever, and you're able to create the same web app over a weekend. You spend 6 hours a day on Saturday and Sunday, in total 12 hours.

That's 10x increase in productivity right there. Did it make you a 10x better programmer? Nope, probably not. But your productivity went up by a tenfold.

And at least to me, that's sort of how it has worked. Things I didn't have motivation or energy to get into before, I can get into over a weekend.

Re:AI is not Making Engineers 10x as Productive by samtp on Tuesday August 05, 2025 @04:01PM (#44803497)
But at the same time you basically outsourced your brain and any learning that would come from the exercise. So while you now have an app, you've experienced close to 0 learning or growth along the way.
Re:AI is not Making Engineers 10x as Productive by nxpnsv on Tuesday August 05, 2025 @12:57PM (#44800681)
However, in the first case you learned something which probably is useful when you want to change said app in any way or make another project...
Re:AI is not Making Engineers 10x as Productive by theshrike79 on Tuesday August 05, 2025 @05:13PM (#44804396)
Depends on how you learn.

For me it's 50-50 reading other people's code and getting a feel for the patterns and actually writing the code.

Re:AI is not Making Engineers 10x as Productive by breakingwalls on Tuesday August 05, 2025 @03:31PM (#44803107)
This, I agree to this 100%. I was able to get at least 2 apps, 2 SAAS products out by pairing up with AI. I was able to learn this as I go and get an app running in the matter of hours than months. Great for prototype to production. -> learn-> fix -> ship -> learn more -> fix things -> ship more.

That being said, I am a generalist with 10+ years of experience and can spot the good parts from bad parts and can wear many hats. Sure, I do not know everything, but, hey did I know everything when AI was not there? I took help from SO, Reddit and other places. Now, I go to AI, see if it makes sense, apply the fix, learn and move on.

Re:AI is not Making Engineers 10x as Productive by dclowd9901 on Tuesday August 05, 2025 @01:11PM (#44800893)
I'm not sure that math makes sense over the long run. Sure, at first you scaffold together an app from scratch, but I suspect over time, the LLM's capability of maintaining it precipitously drops. At some point, you will like reach a productivity level of zero, as now your application has become too complex to fit in a context window and you have no idea how it actually works. So what is the productivity multiplier then?
Re:AI is not Making Engineers 10x as Productive by CER10TY on Tuesday August 05, 2025 @02:35PM (#44802274)
The issue is that it‘ll absolutely _suck_. If I tell Claude Code to scaffold a web app from 0 outside of React it‘s terrible.

So no, imho people with no app dev skills cannot just build something over a weekend, at least something that won‘t break when the first user logs in.

Re:AI is not Making Engineers 10x as Productive by SchemaLoad on Tuesday August 05, 2025 @07:59PM (#44806030)
They will build it, deploy it, get hacked and leak user data.
Re:AI is not Making Engineers 10x as Productive by Quarrelsome on Tuesday August 05, 2025 @04:37PM (#44803933)
you're going to push that straight to production? Cmon man, its not the same thing, not by a long shot. That's a crap measure. I don't think we can even reliably measure 1x developer output which makes multiplying it even more nonsensical.
Re:AI is not Making Engineers 10x as Productive by misja111 on Wednesday August 06, 2025 @03:47AM (#44808969)
This is true, for small projects, one-offs and prototypes AI is great, it will save you loads of time.

However most paid jobs don't fall into this category.

Re:AI is not Making Engineers 10x as Productive by axi0m on Saturday August 09, 2025 @09:55AM (#44846465)
You're talking about a neophyte trying to accomplish an engineering job. So yes, in such case, LLMs dramatically change the game, at least for entry-level tasks. Nowadays, anyone can litteraly pretend to be good/average in any field.

The article relates about actual, experienced engineers trying to get even better. That's a completely different matter.