Re:AI is not Making Engineers 10x as Productive
by thomascgalvin on Tuesday August 05, 2025 @11:21AM
(#44799178)
My experience with GenAI is that it's a significant improvement to Stack Overflow, and generally as capable as someone hired right out of college.
If I'm using it to remember the syntax or library for something I used to know how to do, it's great.
If I'm using it to explore something I haven't done before, it makes me faster, but sometimes it lies to me. Which was also true of Stack Overflow.
But when I ask it to so something fairly complex on it's own, it usually tips over. I've tried a bunch of tests with a bunch of models, and it never quite gets it right. Sometimes it's minor stuff that I can fix if I bang on it long enough, and sometimes it's a steaming pile that I end up tossing in the garbage.
For example, I've asked it to code me a web-based calculator, or a 3D model of the solar system using WebGL, and none of the models I've tried have been able to do either.
If I'm using it to remember the syntax or library for something I used to know how to do, it's great.
If I'm using it to explore something I haven't done before, it makes me faster, but sometimes it lies to me. Which was also true of Stack Overflow.
But when I ask it to so something fairly complex on it's own, it usually tips over. I've tried a bunch of tests with a bunch of models, and it never quite gets it right. Sometimes it's minor stuff that I can fix if I bang on it long enough, and sometimes it's a steaming pile that I end up tossing in the garbage.
For example, I've asked it to code me a web-based calculator, or a 3D model of the solar system using WebGL, and none of the models I've tried have been able to do either.