Re:Google shifts goo.gl policy: Inactive links deactivated, ...
by londons_explore on Friday August 01, 2025 @04:01PM
(#44761758)
I think the concern is someone might scan all the inactive links and find that some of them link to secret URL's, leak design details about how things are built, link to documents shared 'anyone with the link' permission, etc.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Google shifts goo.gl policy: Inactive links deactivated, ...
by cogman10 on Friday August 01, 2025 @04:19PM
(#44762001)
> I think the concern is someone might scan all the inactive links
How? Barring a database leak I don't see a way for someone to simply scan all the links. Putting something like Cloudflare in front of the shortener with a rate limit would prevent brute force scanning. I assume google semi-competently made the shortener (using a random number generator) which would make it pretty hard to find links in the first place.
Removing inactive links also doesn't solve this problem. You can still have active links to secret docs.
Re:Google shifts goo.gl policy: Inactive links deactivated, ...
by bapak on Friday August 01, 2025 @10:12PM
(#44764382)
> You can still have active links to secret docs.
If they're have a (passwordless) URL they're not secret.
Re:Google shifts goo.gl policy: Inactive links deactivated, ...
by londons_explore on Saturday August 02, 2025 @02:33AM
(#44765287)
To make the URLs actually short, you need to use most/all of the keyspace.
Back when it was made, shorteners were competing to see who could make the shortest URL, so I bet a brute force scan would find everything.