News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:‘I witnessed war crimes’ in Gaza – former worker at GHF a... by nailer on Wednesday July 30, 2025 @04:22PM (#44739071)
> You can identify them from satellite images.

Yes because they're buildings.

> The Palestinians are refugees by any reasonable definition.

They are not by UNHCR's definition.

> They were kicked out of their homes by Israel

As discussed, Ben Gurion encouraged Arabs to stay and peacefully join the new state, which is a matter of history and evidenced by Israel's large Arab population. Arab leaders told their people to leave the warzone, which is also documented history. "no u" is not an adequate response.

> > You can jump on TikTok or Instagram right now and see people having fun in cafés car dealerships and restaurants.

> Most buildings in Gaza have been leveled.

lol I just showed you what Arabs are posting from Gaza about their lives and you're still pretending I haven't done that.

> You're like a person in 1943 who believes Nazi propaganda

You're a deeply silly person that belives easily disproven conspiracy theories about Jewish people.

> You're ignoring the millions of Arabs (called "Palestinians") who live under Israeli rule with no rights whatsoever.

No I am not. Those arabs aren't in Israel. Those live outside Israel, with a government that spends most of it's money on trying to destroy Israel. They should get better leaders.

> You're so close to calling me an antisemite.

You are either racist or simply believe racist propaganda, which is fairly commom as a member of the far left. Your background doesn't change anything, identity politics are for the intellectually weak.

> This may be difficult to fathom, but most people are disgusted by seeing Israel's mass murder of Palestinians.

Of course they would be, but you made up those images.

Re:‘I witnessed war crimes’ in Gaza – former worker at GHF a... by DiogenesKynikos on Wednesday July 30, 2025 @04:48PM (#44739329)
> Yes because they're buildings.

You're not reading what I'm writing. They're visible as extremely dense areas, similar to the notorious "walled city" that used to exist inside Kowloon.

> They are not by UNHCR's definition.

They are actually refugees by the UNHCR's definition. Refugee status also applies to families of people who are expelled. The key element is whether their situation has changed so that they are no longer in exile, displaced, stateless, etc. The Palestinians are still all of those things.

> As discussed, Ben Gurion encouraged Arabs to stay and peacefully join the new state, which is a matter of history and evidenced by Israel's large Arab population. Arab leaders told their people to leave the warzone, which is also documented history. "no u" is not an adequate response.

This is just completely delusional. Of all the people you could have chosen to make this argument about, Ben Gurion is the absolute last person you should choose. He is on the record many times as having supported "transfer," which was the term used back then for what we would now call "ethnic cleansing." There are many quotes from him on the subject. Here is one from 1937, as translated by Benny Morris:

"We do not want to dispossess, [but piecemeal] transfer of population [through Jewish purchase and the removal of Arab tenant farmers] occurred previously, in the [Jezreel] Valley, in the Sharon and in other places ... Now a transfer of a completely different scope will have to be carried out ... Transfer is what will make possible a comprehensive [Jewish] settlement programme. Thankfully, the Arab people have vast empty areas [in Transjordan and Iraq]. Jewish power, which grows steadily, will also increase our possibilities to carry out the transfer on a large scale."

And of course, in 1947-48, he actually oversaw the mass expulsion of 80% of the Arab population of the territory that became Israel. Even after the war, Ben Gurion oversaw the passage of the "present absentee" laws that were used to continue expelling Arab civilians from Israel. The reason why there's an Arab minority in Israel today is because the expulsion was not complete. Without the mass expulsions of 1947-48, Israel would never have had anything remotely approaching a Jewish majority in the first place.

> lol I just showed you what Arabs are posting from Gaza about their lives and you're still pretending I haven't done that.

First, anyone who has seen any of the images coming out of Gaza knows that your whole "they're enjoying cafes" line is cynical and absurd. Over a thousand Palestinians have been killed at the food distribution sites, and yet hundreds of thousands of Palestinians continue to regularly risk their lives just to get small boxes of food. Second, the way you regularly refer to them as them "Arabs" instead of "Palestinians" is a dead giveaway that you're a racist.

> You're a deeply silly person that belives easily disproven conspiracy theories about Jewish people.

I'm Jewish, so you'll have to find a different line of attack.

> No I am not. Those arabs aren't in Israel. Those live outside Israel

They live under Israeli rule, surrounded by Israeli settlements and military checkpoints. They functionally live inside Israel. If you go there, the Israeli soldiers will even tell you that you are in Israel. That's how they see it.

> You are either racist or simply believe racist propaganda, which is fairly commom as a member of the far left. Your background doesn't change anything, identity politics are for the intellectually weak.

It's funny how you still want to continue the "you're an antisemite" line of attack, even knowing that you're talking to a Jewish person. You really don't have any better arguments.

> Of course they would be, but you made up those images.

Again, your cynicism is off the charts.

Re:‘I witnessed war crimes’ in Gaza – former worker at GHF a... by nailer on Wednesday July 30, 2025 @05:15PM (#44739580)
Oh god it's the same person. Nevermind.

Actually, fuck it:

> They're visible as extremely dense areas

ok

> They are actually refugees by the UNHCR's definition.

Great let's disband UNRWA then.

> He is on the record many times as having supported "transfer," which was the term used back then for what we would now call "ethnic cleansing."

Do you think Muslims were ethnically cleansed from India? Do you think Hundus were ethnically cleansed from India?

> > lol I just showed you what Arabs are posting from Gaza about their lives and you're still pretending I haven't done that.

> First, anyone who has seen any of the images coming out of Gaza knows that your whole "they're enjoying cafes" line is cynical and absurd.

It's not my line. It's Gazans videos.

> Over a thousand Palestinians have been killed at the food distribution sites, and yet hundreds of thousands of Palestinians continue to regularly risk their lives just to get small boxes of food.

> Second, the way you regularly refer to them as them "Arabs" instead of "Palestinians" is a dead giveaway that you're a racist.

Palestinians aren't a race you silly person.

> > You're a deeply silly person that belives easily disproven conspiracy theories about Jewish people.

> I'm Jewish, so you'll have to find a different line of attack.

No. You're a deeply silly person that belives easily disproven conspiracy theories about Jewish people. Nothing changes that.

> They functionally live inside Israel.

But they don't live in Israel. They live in a country that constantly starts war with Israel, hence checkpoints.

> Of course they would be, but you made up those images.

https://www.wsj.com/opinion/gaza-starvation-photos-tell-a-th...

> > You are either racist or simply believe racist propaganda, which is fairly common as a member of the far left.

> It's funny how you still want to continue the "you're an antisemite" line of attack, even knowing that you're talking to a Jewish person.

No, it's an either/or situation, maybe both. I'll repeat it so you understand: You are either racist or simply believe racist propaganda, which is fairly common as a member of the far left.

Stop getting your news from the BBC and NYT.

Re:‘I witnessed war crimes’ in Gaza – former worker at GHF a... by DiogenesKynikos on Thursday July 31, 2025 @01:47AM (#44742677)
Wow, you're still trying to hammer the "you just hate Jews" line, like an LLM that's gotten stuck in a loop.

I'm Jewish. Find a better argument.

Re:‘I witnessed war crimes’ in Gaza – former worker at GHF a... by nailer on Thursday July 31, 2025 @08:38AM (#44745032)
No. From the comment you are replying to:

> I'll repeat it so you understand: You are either racist or simply believe racist propaganda, which is fairly common as a member of the far left.

Re:‘I witnessed war crimes’ in Gaza – former worker at GHF a... by DiogenesKynikos on Thursday July 31, 2025 @03:53PM (#44749425)
"Racist against Jews" is the same thing as "antisemitism," genius.
Re:‘I witnessed war crimes’ in Gaza – former worker at GHF a... by nailer on Friday August 01, 2025 @09:16AM (#44756346)
Yes. I’ll repeat this for a fourth time so you understand, just because I’m patient:

> You are either racist or simply believe racist propaganda, which is fairly common as a member of the far left.

Re:‘I witnessed war crimes’ in Gaza – former worker at GHF a... by DiogenesKynikos on Saturday August 02, 2025 @06:46AM (#44766469)
Oh, I see - I'm racist against myself. Got it.