Re:I did the scariest thing I can imagine: I resigned
by javert on Tuesday September 04, 2012 @01:47AM
(#4473318)
doesn't sound as though he is claiming that you can't take credit for building a business, just that you can't take all the credit.
Yes, he's saying you can't take all the credit, which means that you can't "take credit" for it.
Taking credit has an implied "all the", as in, "take [all the] credit."
This distinction actually matters. Obama is taking something absolute -- This is my business, these are my profits -- and turning it into something vague. That vagueness leaves plenty of room for all kinds of government controls and taxes.
In fact, contra Obama, if you built a business, it is rightly your business, along with all of the profits (and all of the credit).
Re:I did the scariest thing I can imagine: I resigned
by czr80 on Tuesday September 04, 2012 @07:00AM
(#4474012)
> Taking credit has an implied "all the", as in, "take [all the] credit."
I'm sorry, but this is complete nonsense.
Is more to ignore the rest of the speech. He goes on to say - "The point is, is that when we succeed, we succeed because of our individual initiative, but also because we do things together." - which doesn't sound as though he is claiming that you can't take credit for building a business, just that you can't take all the credit.
Now, I am no fan of Obama (Or roughly 90% of politicians, for that matter), but to try and make out that he was claiming that no-one can take credit for their business, when he clearly states that success comes from individual initiative, is disingenuous at best.