Re:Why does a fire truck cost $2m
by ViscountPenguin on Monday July 28, 2025 @12:50AM
(#44707313)
Tbh, there's a non zero chance it would've been successful if not for insane policies like de baathification.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Iraq's current government is still siginficantly better than Saddam's regime, depsite being currupt and somewhat dysfunctional (and things have improved over the years in case you dig up an article from a decade ago about ISIS).
Re:Why does a fire truck cost $2m
by ashoeafoot on Monday July 28, 2025 @03:39AM
(#44708256)
Is it:
a) a military dictatorship
b) a fanatics hive
c) a familyclan run mafia state.
or a hybrid?
It's a parliamentary democracy with free elections and independent media. It's also chaotic, corrupt, and violent. It's much worse than Sweden or Switzerland but better than many other Arab countries.
Talk to some Iraqis, they’ll tell you they preferred Saddam to the current US puppet government.
And of course preferred that their families hadn’t been killed and homes destroyed.
Depends which Iraqis you talk to, plenty were killed and had their homes destroyed by Saddam.
For the most part, those were the non-Arab minority, predominantly Kurds.
Re:Why does a fire truck cost $2m
by ashoeafoot on Wednesday July 30, 2025 @08:10AM
(#44733148)
You can kill those, they ain't gods chosen masterrace.
Re:Why does a fire truck cost $2m
by actionfromafar on Monday July 28, 2025 @03:19AM
(#44708136)
Hear-hear! Complete own-goal. Let's take everything we learned from the rebuilding of Europe after WW2 and ... ignore it.
Re:Why does a fire truck cost $2m
by volleyball on Monday July 28, 2025 @07:16AM
(#44709661)
As i mentioned in another post, if you measure success as creating a strong, prosperous, independent, viable democracy - then Iraq was an utter failure and so was Libya, Yemen, Somalia, Sudan, Jordan, Egypt and Iran. Which begs the question why does the US pursue the same failed policies over and over again. It turns out we were asking the wrong questions in 2005. If you measure success from the purview of the Yinon plan to establish Israeli hegemony over the entire middle-east then everything aforementioned - including all the death, terrorism, suffering, sectarian and religious strife, massacres and genocides, refugees crises, the rise of ISIS, the recent Al Qaeeda takeover of Syria - everything, was a resounding success.
> Which begs the question why does the US pursue the same failed policies over and over again
Because we’re stupid and very religious. We believe all cultures are the same and basically like Americans, and we don’t understand that Iraq, Libya, etc., had dictators for good reasons. We also seem to have a soft spot for Islamists, who we keep putting in power every time we topple a dictator.