But it's a moot point, since anyone who really wants to defeat captchas en masse, can just go mechanical turk, or even better just setup their own 'porn/warez' sites etc to show your captchas and have random internet users solve it for them.
There's no defense against that... Which makes captchas just a big irritating bag of fail.
Re:Javascript that auto-fills captchas
by irrelative on Friday January 23, 2009 @06:13PM
(#447347)
Indeed! In my experience, the best captcha is asking for a credit card number.
In the same vein, the best captcha is not letting anyone sign up at all.
I think of it as similar to a home security system. Of course there are ways around it. Chances are that the effort involved means that a burglar will go rob a neighbor's house instead though.
Perhaps captchas make more sense in capital intensive industries with clear avenues for abuse. In the case of SpiderOak, we'd prefer to avoid making the free backup accounts an attractive prospect for warez distribution. YMMV.
The primary defense against OCR is to make the segmentation attack hard -- pushing the characters together somewhat. With more tweaking we could probably get closer to a sweet spot of just enough overlap. Not even all of the characters would have to overlap to be effective.