News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Purple Earth Hypothesis by sampo on Saturday July 26, 2025 @04:01PM (#44696557)
> Yes, but why?

Scientific writing style is not always very good at highlighting the unknowns. "We don't know this" doesn't make very convincingly looking text, so people tend to avoid admitting it up front.

But you are, of course, correct to ask.

Like another comments said, this is an open question.

One theory is, that while the algae floating in water were absorbing broad spectrum, the algae growing attached at the bottom of the water evolved to chlorophyll to capture whatever was left at the edges of the spectrum. And then later land-based plants would have evolved from the water plants that were already attaching themselves to the bottom. But then why are also the current ocean-floating algae green now?

http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/Biology/imgbio/pl...

Another theory is that a perfectly-absorbing leaf would somehow absorb too much energy and get overheated, and that it was better to absorb only part of the available light.

None of these theories are fully convincing, so the question remains open.

Re:Purple Earth Hypothesis by enopod_ on Saturday July 26, 2025 @04:57PM (#44696862)
According to the article, at least todays retinal-based photosynthesis is anoxygenic and does not invole carbon fixation. At night, these cells metabolism stops. Chlorophyllic photosynthesis with attached carbon fixation allows the cell to build up starch during the day, which it breathes under the use of oxygen at night, so the cell remains active during the night. Looks like a big evolutionary advantage to me. Also, light is not the limiting factor for plant growth, it‘s usually water or nutrient availability.
Re:Purple Earth Hypothesis by throwawaymaths on Saturday July 26, 2025 @06:05PM (#44697296)
carbon fixation is a completely separate process. in principle you could hook up a sufficiently engineered cell to electrodes and do the carbon fixation part in the dark by supplying it with juice from the mains.

accordingly there is no particular reason for purple photon assimilation to not be attached to carbon fixation... though i suppose as the electron energy levels dont quite match up it might be a schlep to get purples to make sugar.

Re:Purple Earth Hypothesis by tbrownaw on Saturday July 26, 2025 @05:57PM (#44697238)
> "We don't know this" doesn't make very convincingly looking text, so people tend to avoid admitting it up front.

Saying definitively that we don't know something (1) requires an investment of time to verify that lack of knowledge, and (2) can become incorrect at any time.

If you want to do something with the answer but find that it doesn't exist, sure make a note of that to request that someone could maybe try to find out. But if it's just a curiosity rather than directly relevant, why bother?

Re:Purple Earth Hypothesis by khfsoc on Sunday July 27, 2025 @09:46AM (#44701279)
> Saying definitively that we don't know something (1) requires an investment of time to verify that lack of knowledge, and (2) can become incorrect at any time.

And (3) doesn’t necessarily make you lose credibility but too many believe it does and partially it can.

Those who believe science is truth are innocently choosing an answer without full knowledge. That is the definition of religion and faith.

True science is a search for truth like philosophy and theology. I think you can get too caught up in any one of these three.

If you have hard core faith, that’s awesome, but put your faith into that which won’t fail you.

Re:Purple Earth Hypothesis by prerok on Sunday July 27, 2025 @10:45AM (#44701698)
I am sorry but I don't quite agree with you.

In science, there is clear delineation between things we know to be true (laws), things that appear to be true based on our current knowledge (theories) and things that may or may not be true but seem to be true based on limited data/limited research (hypotheses).

I don't think the three (I only see two, though, but don't want to nitpick) approaches are really comparable.

Re:Purple Earth Hypothesis by vcvitae on Sunday July 27, 2025 @12:30PM (#44702461)
Scientific laws are not solid.

Newton's First Law (Law of Inertia) – assumes objects remain at rest or in uniform motion unless acted upon by an external force; inaccurate in non-inertial (accelerating) frames without fictitious forces.

Newton's Second Law – assumes constant mass and low velocities; inaccurate at relativistic speeds where mass increases with velocity.

Newton's Third Law – inaccurate in electromagnetic, quantum, or relativistic contexts.

Newton's Law of Universal Gravitation – assumes instantaneous action at a distance and weak fields; replaced by General Relativity in strong fields or at high velocities.

Boyle's Law – inaccurate at high pressures, low temperatures, or with real gases, which deviate from ideal behavior.

Charles's Law – assumes ideal gas behavior; deviations occur at high pressures or low temperatures.

Ohm's Law – assumes constant resistance; inaccurate for non-ohmic materials like diodes or at high voltages where resistance varies.

2nd Law of Thermodynamics – inaccurate with fluctuations at microscopic scales, temporarily decreasing entropy.

Kepler's Laws – inaccurate when considering relativistic effects.

Laws of Motion of Fluids (e.g., Bernoulli's Law) – assumes incompressible, non-viscous flow; inaccurate for real fluids with viscosity or compressibility effects.

Dalton's Law of Partial Pressures – assumes gases do not interact; inaccurate at high pressures or with strong intermolecular forces.

Fick's Laws of Diffusion - inaccurate in complex systems with reactions or non-constant diffusion coefficients.

Laws of Electromagnetic Induction (Faraday's Law) – assumes ideal conditions; real systems have hysteresis and other non-ideal effects.

Laws of Radioactive Decay – exponential decay is inaccurate as does not fully regard environment or decay chain complexities.

Re:Purple Earth Hypothesis by prerok on Sunday July 27, 2025 @03:18PM (#44703789)
Fair enough. At which point do these non applicabilities make you think that the fact of putting your faith in science is bad? I mean, I tried to point out that science is a process, and yes, laws come with caveats. Some of them are known in advance, some not.

The search for truth, if we are still arguing that, where is it? I don't understand how anybody can argue that the search is the same across theology and science. In a sense it is the search for the same thing, but in so many ways it is not. The commenter I was replying to is confounding the difference, and this comment, seems to ask me to point out what mistakes theology made, and I know of plenty.

Re:Purple Earth Hypothesis by _dark on Sunday July 27, 2025 @12:51PM (#44702614)
So that’s why there are no new laws these days?
Re:Purple Earth Hypothesis by triclops200 on Sunday July 27, 2025 @02:28PM (#44703387)
Principle seems to be the modern equivalent term to the concept that used to be represented by the word "law," in this context. I've also seen them used interchangeably on various things: "principle of least action" vs "law of least action" is a pretty common example.
Re:Purple Earth Hypothesis by megatron2009 on Sunday July 27, 2025 @10:27AM (#44701565)
It is common for authors to say that "We are not aware an explanation as of now."
Re:Purple Earth Hypothesis by Etherlord87 on Saturday July 26, 2025 @07:51PM (#44697828)
How about this: it takes energy to build a photo-synthesis machine. A machine like this won't consume all photons but only some range of electromagnetic spectrum. This is because you need to have such structure to allow light to pass through the outer part of the body of the organism, but be absorbed at a very specific place inside. This is why multi-junction solar cells exist, to use more of the solar spectrum. It would cost a plant more energy to build such a multi-layered chloroplast, so perhaps having just a single layer using a single range of the spectrum is the most optimal (at least as a local maximum).
Re:Purple Earth Hypothesis by flockonus on Sunday July 27, 2025 @01:20AM (#44699062)
> Another theory is that a perfectly-absorbing leaf would somehow absorb too much energy and get overheated

If having both pigments means the plant would be close to black, overheating is an absolutely valid hypothesis imo, plants just like animals have optimal temperature metabolism and often getting too hot is deadly, while under optimal temperature is tolerable.

Re:Purple Earth Hypothesis by geokon on Sunday July 27, 2025 @02:25AM (#44699286)
sure but there are probably ecological niches that are light starved. for instance deeper in the water column or in dark areas like caves or polar regions
Re:Purple Earth Hypothesis by Theodores on Sunday July 27, 2025 @06:00AM (#44700144)
Evolution is only possible along certain paths, for example, we are not going to evolve to have more than four limbs, eyes at the back of our heads or extra hands.

Similarly, at the cell level, we have just the one photosynthesis process in plants and that isn't going to take an entirely different path to work on different wavelengths. The evolutionary investment is in chlorophyll with a magnesium element at the heart of it. Imaginably you would need an entirety different molecule with some other magic atom in the middles of the usual organic chemistry and that isn't going to happen given the sunk cost in the chlorophyll way of doing things. There is a greater chance that we will get six hands than that happening.

Re:Purple Earth Hypothesis by prerok on Sunday July 27, 2025 @11:00AM (#44701814)
Indeed, and frequently you will see that leaves are a much darker hue of green than the ones exposed directly to sunlight. So, using the same mechanism, still more is absorbed if light is scarce.
Re:Purple Earth Hypothesis by flockonus on Monday July 28, 2025 @03:24PM (#44714473)
Of course, for example several sea weeds come to mind in dark green to brown tones; which makes sense, they can disperse heat very fast since they are immersed in cold water / liquid cooling