Re:OSS Rebuild: open-source, Rebuilt to Last
by hollerith on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @10:15PM
(#44655130)
He explains his concerns at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36268776
Re:OSS Rebuild: open-source, Rebuilt to Last
by lrvick on Wednesday July 23, 2025 @09:58AM
(#44659313)
Plenty of wildly unsafe behavior is common in production infrastructure today. This is also why compromised corporate infrastructure is in the news so often. Few orgs hire or even contract security engineers with Linux supply chain and hardening experience, opting to blindly trust the popular options and their maintainers.
NixOS knowingly discards vital supply chain integrity controls to minimize developer friction and maximize package contributions. It is a highly complex Wikipedia style distribution optimizing for maximum package variety which is absolutely fine and great for hobby use cases, but use in security critical applications is absolutely irresponsible.
Guix goes some big steps further in supply chain integrity but still ultimately trusts individual maintainers.
See this chart to understand how NixOS compares in terms of threat model https://codeberg.org/stagex/stagex#comparison
It's hard to know what exactly your security concerns are here, but if you look at the current ecosystem of using containers and package registries, Nix is pretty clearly a solid contender, security-wise.