News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Yoni Appelbaum on the real villians behind our housing an... by cyberax on Monday July 21, 2025 @07:03PM (#44641358)
Austin is a success story in the same way Detroit is.

Austin population cratered and it still has not recovered to 2020 level. That's why the housing costs there decreased.

In other words: force citizens out of your city, and the price will fall.

Re:Yoni Appelbaum on the real villians behind our housing an... by verall on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @01:30AM (#44643519)
This is not true, I don't know if you live here or why you repeat it.

Population has receded slightly in the last couple years in Austin proper, is still greater than 2020, and the metro area has not shrunk year over year at all, although growth has slowed.

Re:Yoni Appelbaum on the real villians behind our housing an... by cyberax on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @01:56AM (#44643629)
> This is not true, I don't know if you live here or why you repeat it.

Population by year:

2019: 978,763

2020 high estimate for Jan 1 (996,369) - https://austin.culturemap.com/news/city-life/01-15-20-austin...

2020: 961,855 (Census, low mark)

2023: 979,882

2024 (estimated high mark): 986,928

So yes, the population cratered from a high in early 2020. This brought down prices with a 2 year lag, as owners started to get rid of empty units. The prices will come right back up now, that the population is recovering.

Re:Yoni Appelbaum on the real villians behind our housing an... by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @10:00AM (#44647018)
Down 4% is not "cratered". Detroit is "cratered".
Re:Yoni Appelbaum on the real villians behind our housing an... by verall on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @11:32AM (#44648407)
You're comparing different estimate sources and still ignoring that someone moving to round rock or ceder park is still a part of the housing pressure for the city of Austin.

A low-single-digit push to local burbs happened all over the country. "Austin" in the same way people discuss "Houston" or "Chicago" i.e. the local metro area has grown every year.

Re:Yoni Appelbaum on the real villians behind our housing an... by cyberax on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @02:57PM (#44651527)
There are different sources (and I pointed that out), but they all show that the population has been at most flat.

The suburbs migration IS the point. The suburbs are a superior model when it's made possible by de-urbanization of workplaces, and it shows. The price in the suburbs of Austin has been growing.

Re:Yoni Appelbaum on the real villians behind our housing an... by renewiltord on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @02:13AM (#44643704)
ACS, the Decennial Census, and the Austin Demographer has the data we need. Let's take a look https://data.census.gov/table/ACSDT1Y2023.B01003?q=B01003:+T... and https://data.census.gov/table/DECENNIALPL2020.P1?q=P1:+TOTAL... (no ACS in 2020 because of COVID, but we got the Census) and https://demographics-austin.hub.arcgis.com/

You'll see that the ACS 1-year was not performed and released in 2020 due to data quality

    2015:  931840

    2016:  947897

    2017:  950714

    2018:  964243

    2019:  979263

    2020:  961855 (Decennial Census), 965,872 (ACS 5-year, not comparable to 1-year), 996369 (Austin City Demographer)

    2021:  964000

    2022:  975335

    2023:  979700

    2025: 1025668

I think there is no single source that shows population decrease post 2020 to a value in 2020 from the same source. But the sources do differ, so likely what has happened is that you have not performed proper data hygiene. You cannot regress across sources without compensating for cross-source differences.

In this case we have the property that 2021 onwards shows increase in ACS and that Austin Demographics shows increase from 2020 onwards but that there is difference between 2020 numbers between sources.

We also see that Austin Demographer has higher number in 2019 than ACS sample https://demographics-austin.hub.arcgis.com/documents/cf1519a...

This means it's probably not good idea to compare 2023 ACS number to 2020 Austin Demographer number. Fortunately, we have Austin Demographer number from 2019, 2020, and 2025. From all this, we can conclude that cratering hypothesis is likely false. We must conclude that following statement of yours is unlikely:

> Austin population cratered and it still has not recovered to 2020 level.

Re:Yoni Appelbaum on the real villians behind our housing an... by cyberax on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @03:01PM (#44651566)
Perhaps you shouldn't use ChatGPT without checking sources?

The purported 2025 number is actually: "Population for City of Austin Full and Limited Purpose Boundaries, 2023".

I indicated that the sources are different. And the conclusion at the very best is that Austin population had been flat for years. It's now growing back, and the prices will react with a lag of 2-3 years.

Re:Yoni Appelbaum on the real villians behind our housing an... by renewiltord on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @03:06PM (#44651626)
You claimed cratering but you mixed sources to produce result. Now trying to deflect with claims about ChatGPT. I did this manually. No LLM involved.

It is embarrassing to be this antagonistic when proven wrong. As the kids say these days: “take the L”.

Re:Yoni Appelbaum on the real villians behind our housing an... by cyberax on Tuesday July 22, 2025 @05:02PM (#44652966)
My sources show unambiguously that the population declined up until at least 2023.

There are no consistent sources for the 2019-2024 population due to the way demographics are counted, so they have to be mixed. But they still show _at_ _most_ a weak return to growth with _at_ _most_ modest increases over the peak 2019 population.

This absolutely supports my point that the reason for the property price drop in Austin was the population decrease in 2020, rather than anything to do with new construction.

And you didn't want to spend 10 seconds to look at that, and instead spammed the thread with AI slop which is demonstrably wrong.