A corporation has a fiduciary duty to act in the best interest of its shareholders, but I think this fact is greatly overstated. Since "best interest" is such a flexible and uncertain concept, most cases where people bring this up are not really the "legal imperative to be assholes" that they believe. By suing Samsung over this, Apple has risked triggering an all out patent war between the major players in the mobile market which could end up costing them tremendous legal fees and may wound them grievously if any of the ensuing lawsuits were not decided in their favor. Suppose Apple had not taken to Samsung to court over these patents. Does it really seem plausible to you that the shareholders would sue Apple's board of directors, and win?
But assuming that corporations are legally expected to perfectly predict the future and optimize for their shareholders' interests, a boycott would still be warranted. If we let companies see that acting like a bully will hurt their bottom line, then those companies will be legally compelled to act in the interest of their shareholders by not being bullies.
It can be a valuable example because it is easy to show how a director making decisions that maximise benefits to the shareholder are not necessarily in the best interests of the company entity, and in fact are viewed with suspicion by regulating bodies.
The best interests of the company include many other considerations besides shareholder return. One of those has to be long term viability for a long lived corporate entity. Eroding goodwill and reputational or brand damage go directly to the heart of the concept of director responsibility.
If you don't like the way a company is legally and ethically running it's business, then change the law. Don't boycott the company who is succeeding best at working within the framework provided.
You seem to be confused about the difference between 'ethical' and 'legally allowed'.
Now, I don't think ideas or design should have a monetary value. But if you live in a world where ideas have currency, then stealing ideas is theft. We need to change the laws so ideas are free to all men. Apple isn't the problem, it's simply the best at navigating the problem.
Btw, the first cellphone was made by Motorola. The first cellphone with MP3 player was made by Samsung. Is Apple riding their R&D?
The Samsung SPH-M100 (aka, the 'Uproar') was the first cellphone that could play MP3s from internal memory, as the SL45 required a MultiMediaCard, but it was beaten to the market by Siemens.
That said, this all comes down to FRAND vs non-FRAND patents all over again. I truly believe that this distinction is something that needs to be clarified or even completely removed if we're going to make any progress on patent reform.
Samsung is leveraging its business on Google's R&D. With Google's consent. Fixed that for you.
Because these are the devices that are being sued here.
There are lot of examples in mans history where this was not the case. This is another one.
You seem to think that anything legally allowed is ethical. That if Apple has an obligation to their shareholders to do X and X is legal, then it's totally ethical for Apple to do X.
That's not what ethical means.
"Vote with your wallet" is a valid strategy. Just because the company you like is at the receiving end, does not change it's validity.
What law says that? I seriously want to know.
Don't boycott the company who is succeeding best at working within the framework provided.
Why not? As a consumer, am I not entitled to buy (or not buy) from whoever I want? Am I really not allowed to take any other factors into account beyond the legality of the company's behavior?
There is no such law here in the UK. I will leave the US corporation law context to someone else with specific knowledge.
You say that it is "actually the law for Apple to make as much money as possible given any legal and ethical [sic] way it can". So, the only way to help Apple management back off from the use of preposterous software patents without the serious risk of breaking that law would be to enact a boycott and create a serious damage to the company image for doing so. A damage that could make that course of action not the one to "make as much money as possible".
Companies are not teams, they are simply the manufacturer of a product that you either bought or chose not to buy. If you don't like the way a company is legally and ethically running it's business, then change the law. Don't boycott the company who is succeeding best at working within the framework provided.