Re:ICE Is Getting Unprecedented Access to Medicaid Data
by ktallett on Friday July 18, 2025 @03:45PM
(#44609005)
No person is illegal as borders are arbitrary, enforced by other humans, not by any real natural divide, hence why they change.
Re:ICE Is Getting Unprecedented Access to Medicaid Data
by huhkerrf on Saturday July 19, 2025 @02:08AM
(#44612980)
Speed limits are also arbitrary, enforced by other humans, not by any real natural divide, hence why they change.
Again, motte and bally.
Re:ICE Is Getting Unprecedented Access to Medicaid Data
by ktallett on Saturday July 19, 2025 @04:02AM
(#44613513)
Speed limits aren't required by nature, we happen to have built machines that are deadly and need control.
Re:ICE Is Getting Unprecedented Access to Medicaid Data
by throw10920 on Saturday July 19, 2025 @08:09PM
(#44620681)
Meanwhile, borders are required by nature, because cultures are not interchangeable and cultural friction exists, rendering borders and controlled assimilation necessary.
You also committed a logical fallacy:
> No person is illegal as borders are arbitrary
That's fallacious. All laws are arbitrary, as the GP pointed out, and you somehow failed to read:
> Speed limits are also arbitrary, enforced by other humans
So, it's factually true that borders are both necessary due to nature, and exist in the legal realm such that "illegal immigrants" is a factually correct label.
Undocumented immigrant is far from a neutral term. They haven't just forgotten their documents, or oops! the government hasn't gotten around to documenting them. They are in the country when they aren't supposed to.
If you really hate the term "illegal immigrant", fine then call them unauthorized immigrants, but the "no person is illegal" slogan is just a motte and balley.