News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Upcoming coordinated security fix for all Matrix server i... by diggan on Thursday July 17, 2025 @11:32AM (#44594466)
> IRC doesn't have chat history

Personally I see that as a feature. Chat is ephemeral, discussions/texts that aren't should be saved elsewhere anyways, otherwise it gets lost with all the other ephemeral stuff.

Re:Upcoming coordinated security fix for all Matrix server i... by barbazoo on Thursday July 17, 2025 @11:52AM (#44594696)
That’s what I thought until I learned that history really seems to refer to persistence. So if you’re not connected, you won’t get messages, even after you reconnect? For many that’s not very useful.
Re:Upcoming coordinated security fix for all Matrix server i... by diggan on Thursday July 17, 2025 @11:54AM (#44594728)
> So if you’re not connected, you won’t get messages

That's true, if you're not connected, you don't receive messages.

> even after you reconnect?

That's not true, once you're connected, you start receiving messages again.

> For many that’s not very useful.

Yeah, I understand it isn't useful if your perspective is that you should be able to read what happened when you were away. But I guess my previous point is that people shouldn't have to do that, there should be another resource for catching up what happened when you were away, and instead it should be OK to return without having to read through all the messages.

Re:Upcoming coordinated security fix for all Matrix server i... by barbazoo on Thursday July 17, 2025 @12:09PM (#44594879)
I can see that in a lot of use cases, yeah. And yes I meant receiving old messages once you reconnect.
Re:Upcoming coordinated security fix for all Matrix server i... by smlavine on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:11PM (#44600143)
I think this is the number one reason more people don't end up using IRC nowadays. The flow for newer, younger users is:

- Use some software project, want to ask a question, see they have an "IRC channel" - Hopefully it's a hyperlink to an IRC web chat, or else they'll have to do a lot of research to find out what IRC is - Join the web chat link, see a room with a list of names - See no messages - Ask a question - Wait ten minutes, get no reply - Assume it's just dead and leave

The ability to see older messages would be a huge boon, and to see messages between connections as well. I've seen it happen that a user joins a channel, they leave because nobody talked to them, somebody answers their question after they leave, they rejoin, they ask the question again, then disconnect.