Consider the source.
People say "well Arrington did it", but I don't think he did. He was genuinely well connected from a long time in the valley. He was genuinely a trusted source. So his posts had insight and were very well written. Not right 100% of the time, in the opinions of many, I'm sure, but who is?
The gossipy nature is distressing. The Twitter squabbles between rival publications are often childish and unnecessary. But there are folks out there trying to build quality alternatives and I have no doubt that things will get better for industry coverage. That in itself may push TC back to quality - let's face it they still run great events and have a loud megaphone in the industry. Swapping that for TMZ-style pageview grasps sounds like an inferior business strategy for the long haul.
But it does seem clearer now why TechCrunch seems to have taken it all so personally. Sounds like they were among those fooled. It really should have been mentioned in the original article that she lived with a TechCruncher. Would have made the personal animosity more transparent. They're obviously embarrassed and lashing out.
However you only have yourself to blame when you fall for easily-fact-checkable lies. If any group has the collective rolodex to make a couple of calls and authenticate the veracity of such claims it's TC.