Re:OpenICE: Open-Source US Immigration Detention Dashboard
by ryandrake on Sunday July 13, 2025 @04:23PM
(#44553384)
Yea I was gonna say: frame it in some quantifiable terms of human suffering, except half the country enthusiastically cheers for human suffering, and would also turn it into a “suffering leaderboard.” We are living in dark times.
Re:OpenICE: Open-Source US Immigration Detention Dashboard
by tehjoker on Sunday July 13, 2025 @04:23PM
(#44553385)
The conservatives care about that but they have no broad political base so they must rely on racists. They’ll tolerate inefficiency so long as they feel they will still be on top. Appealing across the aisle isn’t likely to be impactful. Instead, mobilization of a left base is more useful if they can cause economic chaos for the regime and foil its plans. Don’t forget Kamala had an immigration crackdown plan too, the regime is both parties.
Re:OpenICE: Open-Source US Immigration Detention Dashboard
by holmesworcester on Sunday July 13, 2025 @04:32PM
(#44553459)
Definitely keep it. If someone is focused on the humanitarian aspect of this, they're the choir. No need to preach to them. See my above comment about including some credibly-neutral description of detention conditions, including the psychological aspect of there being zero process and total chaos.
Re:OpenICE: Open-Source US Immigration Detention Dashboard
by danlitt on Sunday July 13, 2025 @05:08PM
(#44553749)
My reply seems at face value to contradict this one, but I don't actually disagree, depending on what you mean by neutral. Certainly any comment should be based in facts, but I would be hard-pressed to describe what the admin is doing both truthfully and in a non-negative light.
Re:OpenICE: Open-Source US Immigration Detention Dashboard
by danlitt on Sunday July 13, 2025 @05:03PM
(#44553709)
I think the lost-revenue number is important and relevant, it underlines the hypocrisy of US fascism to be claiming on the one hand to balance the books while spending billions of dollars on performative cruelty. But I do think only presenting the numbers in isolation is insufficient, and comes off a little strange. Even a little blurb at the top (this is an unprecedented failure of the rule of law, ICE agents frequently arrest people illegally, this kind of thing) would be an improvement. It isn't actually clear at face value whether you think this project is morally wrong, or just expensive.
There are some quantitative questions it would be good to clarify, too. For instance, "convicted criminal" - does this cover people convicted of real crimes, or fake ones engineered by the administration? "pending criminal charges" - are these arrests illegal or likely illegal? should they be portrayed in a hostile light, or just neutrally, as if the courts are going to find these people guilty they just haven't got to it yet. Other useful segments that are relevant include the splitting up of families, the detention of children and the vulnerable, withholding of medication and religious materials. Unfortunately, the list goes on.
Re:OpenICE: Open-Source US Immigration Detention Dashboard
by supermaxman on Sunday July 13, 2025 @05:23PM
(#44553851)
Great feedback, will work on this. Much of the language is from ICE in their released statistics, which is why it is vague. Will improve this for sure
Let me know if you think I could frame it better than I am, always open to feedback