News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A.I. Is Making Sure You Pay for That Ding on Your Rental Car by woodruffw on Saturday July 12, 2025 @11:07PM (#44547161)
> The current process is no less fair and Hertz is no less evil - but in this case its at least impartial and the scans are transparently available.

I don't think it's impartial: the implication here is that the same technology is not available to the renter, so Hertz can easily claim damage that was already present at checkout that an ordinary customer picture can't refute. That asymmetry seems bad to me.

Re:A.I. Is Making Sure You Pay for That Ding on Your Rental Car by tekla on Sunday July 13, 2025 @12:14AM (#44547442)
That's weird, because when I rent a car, I take photos and videos and I make sure to have a attendant write down the damage on the rental paper before I drive away.

Is basic ass covering weird?

Re:A.I. Is Making Sure You Pay for That Ding on Your Rental Car by woodruffw on Sunday July 13, 2025 @12:22AM (#44547480)
> Is basic ass covering weird?

The point was that basic ass covering isn't good enough; my visual scan and phone photos aren't going to match what a machine designed to find defects can do.

(I think everyone does - or at least should do - what you do. I certainly do.)

Re:A.I. Is Making Sure You Pay for That Ding on Your Rental Car by tekla on Sunday July 13, 2025 @12:29AM (#44547515)
I would need examples of the defects that this machine would find that a) would matter enough to bother with and b) not be something a human could bring up arbitrarily too if they happened to not like me.
Re:A.I. Is Making Sure You Pay for That Ding on Your Rental Car by woodruffw on Sunday July 13, 2025 @02:09AM (#44547911)
This is a lot more complicated than assuming that a machine will find things more consistently than a ~minimum wage employee, especially if the latter isn't motivated to screw you.

(It's also far from the original point, which is purely about symmetry.)

Re:A.I. Is Making Sure You Pay for That Ding on Your Rental Car by esseph on Sunday July 13, 2025 @01:09AM (#44547700)
In theory if the success rate is high enough, it will find more than most humans will.

Edit: And as another poster said, this means they get to double dip by depreciating the asset and charging the customer for that wear.

Re:A.I. Is Making Sure You Pay for That Ding on Your Rental Car by BoorishBears on Tuesday July 15, 2025 @07:11PM (#44576890)
Unless you carry a dent repair light in a darkened room, you're not matching their level of detail fwiw

If you put most people's cars under those lights you'd be shocked at how much damage you'd find.