The free market generally does not have the power to correct for overreaching management. In many cases the signal necessary to make a judgement is not propagated to consumers, at least not in such a way that it will cause a change in consumers purchasing decisions. This is where unions are necessary to correct against overbearing and unrealistic management. Society is stronger, and the economy is stronger, when the "wealth" of a nation is well distributed among everyone. Wealth here being everything from health, leisure time, assurances against bodily injury, etc. Unions are but one tool to ensure this equitable distribution.
You say "profit" like it's a bad thing. It's not, it's what funds new good things. And, reducing costs is a good thing. It produces "more".
BTW - Management's goal is to extract as much profit for managers, not for the enterprise.
One big problem with the corporate model is that no one has a long term interest. No one at GM ever got fired for agreeing to the contracts that broke the company. Instead, folks did get fired for not giving in.
Even if that's true, unions aren't a balancing force to the "incentives for all sorts of bad things". The only role that unions will play here is in trying to get their cut.
Actually, that's wrong. Unions will often actively help commit said "bad things" because they'll benefit. For example, unions are often quite protectionist.
The question isn't whether unions are good or evil, it's whether they're actually a counter to a specific evil that companies might commit.
Since that evil produces more money for the company, you need an example where a union did something to reduce a company's profit other than by trying to increase the union's cut.
Unions are not new, so if you're going to suggest that they're useful for doing something, you should have actual examples of them doing said something.
All of those things are the union (members) taking more of the profit.
"work environment" (as you're using it) isn't some abstract good that the unions are protecting. It's "what do I have to do for the money I make?"
Changing that balance one way is reducing the union members' take. Changing it the other way is increasing the union members' take, that is, trying to reduce a company's profit by increasing the union members' share of the revenue.
We're still waiting for "an example where a union did something to reduce a company's profit other than by trying to increase the union's cut."
>The question isn't whether unions are good or evil, it's whether they're actually a counter to a specific evil that companies might commit.
The specific evil being detrimental work environment, its obvious that unions are a balancing for to that.
I'm not trying to be snarky. I'm trying to point out that your thinking is muddled.
> I was clear that I meant "profit" in terms of money.
And the things that you listed were benefits received by union members, benefits that cost money, which reduces profit. What do you think the same money for less work is?
> clarified my point by listing the ways unions benefit their members.
No one is suggesting that unions don't benefit their members. Your claim was that unions were combatting some evils. I asked for an example, and you started ranting about profits, so I pointed out that the only effect that unions have on profits is to increase expenses that directly benefit their members.
> If you consider work environment, etc as part of "profit
Work environment is expense. Profit is revenue - expense. Which statement do you disagree with?
Some work environment details affect quality and/or productivity and some don't. Of the former, some provide more increased revenue than their costs while others don't.
Do you really want to argue that unions only ask for work environment and compensation things that "pay for themselves"? (Given your model of management, unions don't have to ask for those things.)
If you've got examples of unions acting other than in their own self-interest, let's see them instead of vague theories.
How can you be so certain that unions act a certain way yet not have any examples?
>Work environment is expense. Profit is revenue - expense. Which statement do you disagree with?
I have no problem with the definition of "profit" you used, I already made this clear. All that matters is that we're on the same page.
>No one is suggesting that unions don't benefit their members. Your claim was that unions were combatting some evils
I clearly defined what "evil" I spoke of that unions are a balancing force against--"overbearing" management. Things like dangerous work environments, extreme work hours, lack of health insurance, etc. It is clear that unions are a balancing force to this "evil". If you disagree with this, then provide an argument. This is the only point I've made. I never claimed that this wasn't in the self-interest of its members. Your points are completely tangential to anything I've said.
I'll agree with that, but I think regulation and Big Government™ are a better solution and unions have outlived their usefulness. You can tell because most people who advocate for unions just rest on past glories.
Seriously, you need to work on your language and mindset if you think profit is evil.
Profit is just a surplus of outputs for inputs given. It's what makes people get out of bed in the morning. It is most definitely not evil.
Can you explain this claim? Specifically, why "overreaching management" is bad for consumers, and why the market can't correct for it?
As to why the market won't necessarily correct for it, is because many times overreaching management is effective (at least in the short term). Degrade working conditions to cut costs and the consumer benefits. The information about how these lower prices were brought to the consumer is usually lost in the process. That signal simply doesn't reach all interested parties, and thus they aren't able to adjust their behavior in response. Some situations it can work, for example a business where customer service is a large part of the experience. The signal of overreaching management does eventually filter down to the consumer.
There are often niche producers who target the small fraction of consumers who care, and market their wares in part based on this. For example, see Fair Trade coffee producers (appealing to do-gooders) or American Apparel (appealing to US nationalists).
Your claim that markets can't transmit this information to interested consumers seems incorrect.
Sure it does. I, the customer, see both the price and the service. If I'm willing to pay more for more service, I can do so.
And, this signal also reaches the employees as well. If you don't like it, go elsewhere. If you're right about how valuable your service is, customers will make the same choice. If you're wrong....
This does not at all correspond to my experience.
I don't think it's at all arguable that unions--at least American unions--are detrimental to the health of the businesses their employees work for.
Fundamentally, these unions are parasitic. They treat the wealth of its host as a given and find ways to extract more of that wealth. The flaw behind this is that the wealth of a company is not a given--it depends upon the customers, and the more you try to extract wealth from the company, the greater the impact on the customer. Either that, or the company just goes flat broke[1]. A company that doesn't have these additional costs and distractions is more able to focus on the customer, or at the very least can do just as good a job without going flat broke. The experience of US automakers vs foreign competitors, or Boeing vs Airbus, or unionized retail vs. Wal-Mart and Amazon, bears this out.
[1] If the company just goes flat broke, then the union isn't a problem per se, just a con game on shareholders. Airlines are an example: http://philip.greenspun.com/flying/unions-and-airlines