Re:Low-Calorie Diet Doesn’t Prolong Life, Study of Monkeys F...
by enraged_camel on Wednesday August 29, 2012 @04:40PM
(#4451010)
Can you elaborate on how a calorie-restricted diet can result in "increased energy and stamina"? Specifically, if your energy intake is minimal, how do you end up with more energy than you had in your previous diet?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Low-Calorie Diet Doesn’t Prolong Life, Study of Monkeys F...
by gwern on Wednesday August 29, 2012 @04:57PM
(#4451183)
More calories doesn't translate straight into more energy or stamina, or athletes would just consume big blocks of lard.
Re:Low-Calorie Diet Doesn’t Prolong Life, Study of Monkeys F...
by enraged_camel on Wednesday August 29, 2012 @05:53PM
(#4451574)
Your statement strikes me as patently false. Athletes eat a ton of food while training. Michael Phelps, for example, eats over 10,000 calories per day.
Re:Low-Calorie Diet Doesn’t Prolong Life, Study of Monkeys F...
by gwern on Wednesday August 29, 2012 @10:05PM
(#4452533)
And Phelps is all athletes? And what is he eating? I'd bet it's not optimized for caloric density.
Re:Low-Calorie Diet Doesn’t Prolong Life, Study of Monkeys F...
by enraged_camel on Thursday August 30, 2012 @02:01PM
(#4455877)
The point was not that Phelps is a representation of all athletes, but rather that athletes do eat a ton of calories a day in order to build muscle mass and have enough stamina for their rigorous training. There are certain exceptions, but generally speaking, if you are training for a sport then you should have a solid diet.
Re:Low-Calorie Diet Doesn’t Prolong Life, Study of Monkeys F...
by philwelch on Thursday August 30, 2012 @01:08PM
(#4455618)
It's probably physically impossible to eat 10,000 calories a day unless some of it is calorie dense.
Re:Low-Calorie Diet Doesn’t Prolong Life, Study of Monkeys F...
by mistercow on Wednesday August 29, 2012 @06:05PM
(#4451641)
"Energy" in the sense of "I have a lot of energy today" is only tangentially related to "energy" in the sense of "the energy content of this candy bar is 250 calories".
Re:Low-Calorie Diet Doesn’t Prolong Life, Study of Monkeys F...
by aezell on Thursday August 30, 2012 @09:28AM
(#4454486)
Most of the other replies here got the gist of what I wrote, but for me, it's about apparent energy levels. That is, because I don't feel weighed down and sluggish because of a huge, greasy meal, I'm more apt to get outside and play basketball with my son or go for a walk, etc.
Re:Low-Calorie Diet Doesn’t Prolong Life, Study of Monkeys F...
by manfredz on Wednesday August 29, 2012 @04:56PM
(#4451169)
Your body is probably spending less time and energy digesting the food.
Re:Low-Calorie Diet Doesn’t Prolong Life, Study of Monkeys F...
by ktizo on Wednesday August 29, 2012 @04:53PM
(#4451153)
Presumably, there is a peak efficiency of the digestive system where it is using the least energy in metabolism compared to the intake, which when combined with weighing less, so needing less energy to move, could mean that people eating relatively little in general could feel more energetic than someone eating far more. This becomes really obvious if you look at the upper end of the spectrum.