In terms of the front-end, there’s really no limit imposed by Next.js and it’s not limited to a narrow band of the problem (whatever that gibberish means), so I don’t know what you’re even talking about.
> How are we solving that today with Islands or RSCs?
Next.js/RSC solves it by loading JavaScript only for the parts of the page that are dynamic. The static parts of the page are never client-side rendered, whereas before RSC they were.
This is fine generally because you have the choice to pick the right tool for the job, but in the context of "a single, cohesive unit" you can only get that with Next.js if you all that you care about are those specific abstractions and want your backend and frontend to be in the same language. Even then you run into this awkwardness where you have to really think about where your JavaScript is running because it all looks the same. This might be a personal shortcoming, but that definitely broken the illusion of cohesion for me.
> The static parts of the page are never client-side rendered, whereas before RSC they were.
Didn't the hydration performance issues start when we started doing the contemporary SSR method of isomorphic javascript? I think Islands are great and it's a huge improvement to how we started doing SSR with things like Next.js Pages Router. But that's not truly revolutionary industry wide because we've been able to do progressive enhancement long before contemporary frameworks caught up. The thing I'm clarifying here is the "before RSC" only refers to what was once possible with frameworks like Next.js and not what was possible; you could always template some HTML on the server and progressively enhance it with JavaScript.
How much of the frontend and how much of the backend are we talking about? Contemporary JavaScript frameworks only cover a narrow band of the problem, and still require you to bootstrap the rest of the infrastructure on either side of the stack to have something substantial (e.g., more than just a personal blog with all of the content living inside of the repo as .md files).
> while avoiding the hydration performance hit
How are we solving that today with Islands or RSCs?