You seem to be tightly focusing on a possible reading† of the second-to-last sentence of my comment. I'm not sure why. It doesn't matter if older people have zero evolutionary benefit or simply less evolutionary benefit — the point is that evolution does not necessarily optimize for longevity (certainly not to the point where we can't do better than simply looking at how our basic instincts).
† I actually anticipated a response like this, which is why I added "clear." The evolutionary benefit of a grandparent is a lot less clear-cut and immediate than the benefit of a parent. Clearly I still did not communicate that well enough.
My point is that nobody has yet presented enough evidence to argue that simply "listening to our bodies" rather than taking any proactive measures is the best path to longevity. The view that evolution has given us natural lifespans that are as long as can be doesn't seem to be supported by the evidence.
When we talk about longevity these days, we're not talking about living long enough to raise children — we're talking about living way past the point where we serve any clear evolutionary purpose. Thus, evolution might not be the best guide.