Re:Is a GED More Valuable Than a PhD?
by puzzle-out on Thursday January 22, 2009 @02:15PM
(#445219)
English phd students tend to be quite a despondant lot (I have one, but avoided most of the other students on the course).
One major advantage of doing a phd in the humanities now (providing you get funding) is the flexibility. I knew about the job prospects for English phds before I started, but I was fascinated by the period and was offered a scholarship, so thought why not, but I also used the spare time I had to set up an internet company - which we sold for a modest amount the same week I passed my viva.
People worry too much about following the herd - partly because they read too many articles like this.
A hard science Ph.D. is a bad financial investment. But, as bad investments go, you could do much, much worse.
The bigger problem that afflicts a lot of Ph.Ds -- especially the ones in this article -- is not so much financial as spiritual: They have a gauzy vision of the Intellectual Lifestyle that they just can't let go of. I'm fortunate in that I didn't emerge from grad school expecting to be raptured into the Academy. Studying engineering was a very helpful dose of reality, as was the emerging Internet, which made it possible to sit at a desk deep inside the university and still experience the words of people who had non-academic jobs and were enthusiastic about them, like Greenspun and, later, Spolsky and PG.