The second way is by exploiting something. Exploiting people's desires to provide for their children. Exploiting their financial illiteracy. Scamming people, in other words. This is also a successful business model, in that it works for the business (bad for society, of course).
We have something that looks like a duck and walks like a duck. We have not actually heard it quack like a duck, not yet. But the question in my mind is, how COULD this be a successful business? The product being offered has zero or negative value to almost everyone[1], and this is an age of financial scams of various sorts, the "grifter economy" as it has been dubbed. Am I so off-base in suggesting that this might be one of them? Am I crazy?
[1] Just a caveat: trust funds can be useful in a few cases, but you aren't rich enough to benefit.
Trust funds are a liability shield.
> ... your parents should have kept the money in their bank account.
Where it can be taken in a personal injury claim, or seized as alimony by a vindictive ex wife, or spent down by a the parent's medical trustee, or hundreds of other financial disasters.
The point of establishing a trust fund is to give a young person money that cannot easily be diverted or frittered away. Strings can be attached so that a teenager does not destroy themselves with money.
P.S. Companies like this make money by keeping overhead low and scaling up to bazillions of customers. You don't have to be a cheat or even expensive if you can get 10,000,000 customers.
Couldn't it also be a way for low-income families to benefit from the tax advantages normally only afforded to the wealthy?
But let me address your second question.
The way that a trust is set up, it's not always the best solution for reducing the cost of college, particularly if you think you will qualify for financial aid (though that's a very difficult projection to make for the year 2030 at this point).
The way financial aid is calculated, these assets count against your eligibility. So while having the money won't 'hurt' you in some sense, there's the possibility that you'd receive that money from financial aid anyway, and by saving e.g. $10,000, you've reduced your financial aid eligibility by the same amount.
Of course, if you are able to save up the cost of college (>$200,000 for private schools) over two decades - or at least come reasonably close - then yes, it is good to have that money at the end of the term in case you wouldn't have qualified for financial aid anyway, but as you can see, having the fund doesn't necessarily leave you better off than the alternative.
The kicker is that the very-wealthy are able to secure vast amounts of financial aid for their children. I went to an Ivy League school, so I'll speak to their policies, as all Ivy League schools but one have the same financial aid policy: guaranteed to meet 100% of 'demonstrated need'. The problem is that 'demonstrated need' is very easy to manipulate if you're savvy enough to know how to reduce your taxable income, reduce your child's net worth to zero (or less), and exploit several other loopholes that are nevertheless entirely legal.
The end result is that I had some classmates whose families were wealthy enough to donate tens of thousands of dollars in charitable donations, and yet they also received the top financial aid packages reserved for the 'high need' (ie, very poor) families.
All of that is orthogonal to the company we're discussing: it's possible they may help, and it's possible that they may 'do no harm' (ie, it will be a wash for the family). Or they may be able to help educate these families how to take advantage of those same loopholes, but that would be difficult, and it's completely unrelated to the business of simply having a trust.
However, in my opinion, promoting individual saving for higher education and reducing government subsidies is a positive step. Because of the uncertainty about the situation in 2030 (as you mentioned) and government subsidies tend to lead to unintended consequences (see housing price bubble and collapse).
Edit: Also, the money doesn't have to be used for college.
Putting money in a trust fund for your child will reduce their eligibility for financial aid, full stop, no doubt about it.
Low-income families aren't going to be taxed on any of the money they gift to their children.
At all of these schools, while the tuition price tag might be $50,000 per year or more, relatively few families actually have to pay this sticker price. At my alma mater, Bowdoin, the overall cost is around $54k, but the average financial aid package (according to the College Board) is $41k, leaving the average Bowdoin student on the hook for only $13k a year.
If you're a family that otherwise would qualify for a large amount of financial aid, but you've saved up into a trust or other savings plan for the purpose of funding your child's education, you'll lose this free money. The institution will count this amount against your demonstrated financial need.
Some families with means are able to hide away these funds, and still get significant financial aid from a school like Bowdoin, but most families don't have the resources or savvy to do so.
Of course, if we're talking about institutions that don't have such strong financial aid programs – which is the vast majority – you probably want that savings. Deciding to save for your child's education is, statistically, usually a good decision. If your child ends up going to one of the above, though, it can be a costly one.
The "maximum you can possibly afford" goes up on almost a 1:1 basis for every dollar in the child's name.
You might as well just write the check directly to the college as a donation. At least you can deduct it as a charitable donation that way (assuming it's a qualified non-profit blah blah).
Family A: parents have $10K, child has nothing
Family B: child has $10K, parents have nothing
Family B will be calculated to have more money available to spend on college (OBVIOUSLY the child should pay for college out of his own assets first...) and will get less financial aid. This will be true 18 years from now even if the system is tweaked slightly in the meantime.
http://www.moneyville.ca/article/1244729--fees-eat-up-90-per...
Be sure to market it to the poor primarily. The marketing tagline can be something like "The wealthy use trust funds to provide for their children - now you can too!"
Should be highly successful, even though there are zero benefits to trust funds for 99% of the population. Actually it's probably a net minus for most people, due to the way college financial aid is calculated.
I give it an A+ for income potential, C- for utility, F for ethicality.