Re:Everything around LLMs is still magical and wishful thinking
by alganet on Monday July 07, 2025 @05:42PM
(#44494976)
I just did.
By pretending to know less of egyptian culture and the academic consensus around it, I played the role of a typical human (not trained to prompt, not smart enough to catch bullshit from the LLM).
I then compared the LLM output with real information from specialists, and pointed out the mistakes.
Your attempt at discrediting me revolves around trying to estabilish that my specialist information is not good, that ancient aliens is actually fine. I think that's hilarious.
More importantly, I recognize the LLMs failing, you don't. I don't consider them to be good enough for a gullable audience. That should be a big sign of what's going on here, but you're ignoring it.
https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/PZtsoaoSLpKjjbMqM/the-case-f...
There's some extra commentary from the reviewers of earlier drafts here:
https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/AyfDnnAdjG7HHeD3d/miri-comme...
I've skimmed both of these - this is some substantial and pretty insightful reading (though 2021 was ages ago - especially now that AI safety stopped being a purely theoretical field). However, as of now, I can't really see the connections between the points being discussed there, and anything you tried to explain or communicate. Could you spell out the connection for us please?